NEET PG | In-Service Doctors Defend Incentive Marks Before MP High Court, Say They Took Rural Postings With 'Legitimate Expectation' Of Benefits
In-service doctors have defended the grant of incentive marks for rural and remote service before the Madhya Pradesh High Court, arguing that they had accepted such postings with a 'legitimate expectation' of receiving additional marks while seeking admission to postgraduate medical courses.
A Division Bench of Chief Justice Alpesh Y. Kogje and Justice Vivek Jain was hearing a petition filed by fresh NEET PG candidates challenging the grant of service-based incentive marks to in-service doctors in addition to the 30% quota earmarked for them.
The petitioners contended that under Rule 14 of the MP Chikitsa Shiksha Pravesh Niyam, 2018, in-service candidates receive incentive weightage based on their length of service. They argued that these additional marks artificially improve the merit positions of in-service doctors, adversely affecting fresh candidates who have secured higher NEET PG scores.
Earlier, the High Court had directed the State to ensure that admissions of in-service candidates to postgraduate medical courses remained restricted to the 30% seats earmarked for them under the existing seat distribution framework.
During the hearing, counsel appearing for the intervening in-service doctors argued that the Medical Council of India (MCI) Postgraduate Medical Education Regulations, in place since 2018, provided for reservation as well as incentive weightage based on the duration and nature of service.
He submitted that the doctors had accepted postings in rural and remote areas on the understanding that they would receive these benefits when seeking postgraduate medical admission.
"I pointed out that we are the ones who are given three years in remote areas, based on which we are required to get this incentive as per Rules which were provided since 2018," counsel submitted.
Invoking the principle that the rules of a selection process cannot be changed midway, counsel argued that the doctors had entered service relying on the existing framework.
"The rules of the game cannot be changed midway. This started in early 2023, when we were getting into this," he submitted.
The intervenors further argued that in-service doctors would also be required to execute a five-year service bond after postgraduate admission. According to counsel, this would mean that doctors who had already served three years in rural or remote areas could ultimately spend eight to nine years in such postings.
"After three years, I will again give service for 5 years. My service part alone would be 8-9 years in rural, remote areas," he stated.
At the previous hearing, the Additional Solicitor General appearing for the State had defended the grant of incentive marks alongside the reservation available to in-service candidates.
Referring to the Supreme Court's decision in Tamil Nadu Medical Officers Association v. Union of India and the Madras High Court's decision in Gurubaran v. Union of India, the State had argued that the concept of merit was not confined to academic performance but also included professional experience.
It was submitted that amendments to the applicable regulations had removed the reference to "academic merit", thereby broadening the scope of merit to recognise service experience.
Opposing these submissions, Senior Counsel appearing for the petitioners argued in rejoinder that in-service doctors were already receiving the benefit of seats reserved exclusively for them.
He suggested that the State could formulate a mechanism to accommodate different levels of incentive weightage within the 30% seats earmarked for in-service candidates.
"The State could create formula where first preference or choice is given to 30%, second to 20% and third to 10% within the in-service seats," he submitted.
Relying on the Supreme Court's decision in Satyabrata Sahoo v. State of Orissa (2012), counsel argued that fresh and in-service candidates constituted distinct categories and that the latter could not be merged with the open category in a manner that adversely affected academic merit.
The High Court concluded the hearing and directed the parties to submit their written arguments.
For Petitioners: Senior Advocate Aditya Sanghi with Advocates Alka Singh, Nain Jyoti Noriya, and Vinita Ahuja
For the State: Additional Advocate General Janhavi Pandit with Government Advocate R.D Pararha
For the Respondent (National Medical Commission): Senior Advocate Anoop Nair with Advocate Akashmi Trivedi
For Intervenors (in-service candidates): Advocates Siddharth Seth, Parag Tiwari, Amit Kumar Singh, Atul Kumar Jain, Dinesh Kumar Upadhyay, Anubhav Singhal, and Harsh Chouhan