Marriage Between Hindu And Christian Can't Be Validated By Registration Under Hindu Marriage Act: Madras High Court
The Madras High Court has held that the marriage between a Hindu and a Non-Hindu cannot be solemnised under the Hindu Marriage Act and such a marriage cannot be validated by mere registration. [2026 LiveLaw (Mad) 556] The bench of Justice CV Karthikeyan and Justice S Raveekumar thus declared a marriage between a Christian man and a Hindu woman void, holding that the marriage could not...
The Madras High Court has held that the marriage between a Hindu and a Non-Hindu cannot be solemnised under the Hindu Marriage Act and such a marriage cannot be validated by mere registration. [2026 LiveLaw (Mad) 556]
The bench of Justice CV Karthikeyan and Justice S Raveekumar thus declared a marriage between a Christian man and a Hindu woman void, holding that the marriage could not have been solemnised under the Hindu Marriage Act.
“A plain reading of the said provision makes it clear that a marriage under the Act can be solemnized only between two Hindus..Therefore, a conjoint reading of Sections 5 and 8 of the Hindu Marriage Act makes it clear that a marriage between a Hindu and a person professing a different religion cannot be solemnized and validated by a mere registration under the said Act,” the court said.
The court was hearing an appeal filed by a man challenging an order of the Family Court, by which his plea to declare his marriage as null and void was rejected.
The man's case was that the woman had approached him for assistance in a project work and had then claimed to be in love with him. The man submitted that though he rejected her proposal and moved to Bangalore, the woman continued to send him messages. The man submitted that on February 20, 2009, the woman had asked him to come to Chennai to sign as a witness to her marriage with another person.
The man submitted that only later he came to know that the registration was in fact a registration of marriage between himself and the woman.
The man argued that the marriage was void in law and contrary to Section 5 of the HMA as he was Christian. He submitted that the woman had committed fraud and made misrepresentation before the Registrar at the time of registration, without his knowledge or consent.
The woman, on the other hand, submitted that the man had approached her and though she had initially refused, she had later accepted his proposal. The woman also denied the allegation that the man did not know about the marriage and submitted that all arrangements for the marriage was made by the man.
The court noted that the trial court had rejected the man's plea holding that his plea of having undergone baptism was not believable in view of contradictions in his evidence. The trial court had held that the man had not converted into Christianity prior to the marriage, that compulsion by the woman had not been proved and that the version put forth by the man was not reliable.
The court noted that the man had undergone baptism in 1998 and again in 2006 when he decided to follow Pentecostal faith. The court noted that the trial court had wrongly considered this as a contradiction between the dates. The court noted that baptism was conducted not just when a person converts to Christianity but when a person converted from one community of Church or Christianity to another.
“The Trial Court failed to appreciate that baptism is a religious ceremony performed not only in the case of a person converting to Christianity but also in the case of a person born into a Christian family. Baptism serves as a ritual to permit an individual to join a different community or Church of Christians, from the another community or Church. The Trial Court failed to note the subtle difference in such rituals,” the court said.
The court noted that the records show that the man's father and mother had also undergone baptism and had showed documents to prove the same. The court also noted that the woman had not specifically disputed the man's claim regarding his religious status.
The court also remarked that merely because a person had a name commonly associated with a particular religion, it would not be a ground to presume the religious identity of the person. The court held that in a country like India, where people from different religions co-existed, it was not uncommon for persons from different religion to have names that were common across religions.
“Similarly, it is pertinent to state that merely because a person bears a name commonly associated with a particular religion or faith, the same cannot, by itself, be a ground to determine or presume the religious identity of such person. In a country like India, where people belonging to different religions and faiths coexist, it is not uncommon for persons professing different religions to have names that are common across religions or are traditionally associated with a particular faith. Therefore, the name of a person, by itself, cannot be relied upon to reject or disbelieve the claim made by such person regarding the religion professed by him,” the court said.
Thus, considering the materials, the court held that the man was a Christian at the time of alleged marriage and the trial court's finding to the contrary was not sustainable. The court thus set aside the order.
Counsel for Appellant: Mr. N. Easwaran and Mr. R. Veeramani