The Patna HC has held that a public servant who retired before cognizance was taken against him cannot claim protection under Section 19 of the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988, merely because the alleged offences were committed during his official tenure. The Court further observed that protection under Section 197 CrPC cannot automatically be invoked simply because the alleged acts were performed while holding public office.

A Single Judge Bench of Justice Chandra Shekhar Jha dismissed a petition filed by a former Circle Officer seeking quashing of criminal proceedings relating to alleged irregularities in the issuance of a land possession certificate and the sanctioning of an agricultural loan.

The case arose from a complaint filed on July 11, 2006, alleging that certain persons, acting in connivance and misusing their official positions, had facilitated the issuance of a possession certificate in favour of another individual and the grant of an agricultural loan, thereby causing wrongful loss to the complainant.

Following an enquiry by the Vigilance authorities, an FIR was registered on December 10, 2010, for offences under Sections 420, 467, 468, 471 and 120-B IPC and Sections 7, 8 and 13 of the Prevention of Corruption Act. The petitioner, who was serving as Circle Officer, Saraiya, at the relevant time, was accused of involvement in the manner in which the report concerning the land was processed and forwarded.

Subsequently, the Special Judge, Vigilance, North Bihar, Muzaffarpur, took cognizance of the alleged offences on September 7, 2015. Aggrieved, the petitioner approached the High Court seeking quashing of the cognizance order. The petitioner contended that he had merely discharged his official duties by forwarding a report prepared by the Halka Karamchari after verification of the land records. He submitted that he had no independent role in the alleged irregularities and that the agricultural loan had subsequently been repaid with interest. He further relied upon his long and unblemished service record and the fact that he had retired in 2013.

Examining these submissions, the High Court held that whether the petitioner had merely forwarded a genuine report or had participated in the alleged irregularities required appreciation of the evidence collected during investigation. The Court observed that the petitioner's claim of having acted bona fide could not be conclusively determined while exercising its inherent jurisdiction to quash criminal proceedings.

Addressing the question of protection available to public servants under Section 19 of the Prevention of Corruption Act and Section 197 CrPC, the Court observed:

“The aforesaid principle has direct relevance to the present case. The petitioner admittedly retired in the year 2013, whereas cognizance was taken on 07.09.2015. Therefore, the protection under Section 19 of the Prevention of Corruption Act cannot be invoked on the ground that the petitioner was a public servant when the alleged occurrence took place. Further, the plea of protection under Section 197 Cr.P.C. cannot be accepted merely because the alleged acts were performed during his tenure as Circle Officer. Whether the acts complained of were genuinely connected with the discharge of official duty or whether the official position was used in furtherance of the alleged irregularity is a matter which requires examination on the basis of evidence.”

The Bench also referred to the distinction between acts genuinely performed in the discharge of official duties and criminal acts committed by using public office as a means of facilitating unlawful gains. It observed that protection under Section 197 CrPC is available where the alleged offence is connected with the discharge or purported discharge of official duties, but not where the official position merely serves as a cloak for unlawful conduct.

The Court further rejected the argument that subsequent repayment of the agricultural loan with interest justified quashing the prosecution. It held that repayment did not erase the allegations concerning the manner in which the loan was sanctioned or the alleged irregularities involving the possession certificate and land records. Such repayment could be considered during trial but was not, by itself, sufficient to terminate criminal proceedings.

The Bench also noted that the investigation had already culminated in a chargesheet and that the competent court had taken cognizance of the offences. It held that where the materials collected during investigation disclose a prima facie case requiring adjudication, the High Court should not substitute its own assessment of the evidence for that of the trial court.

Finding that the allegations were neither inherently improbable nor absurd and that sufficient material existed to warrant a trial, the High Court refused to quash the criminal proceedings. The Court clarified that it had not expressed any opinion on the merits of the allegations or the petitioner's defence and directed that the trial court consider the evidence independently.

Accordingly, the petition was dismissed.

Appearance:

For the Petitioner: Mr. Javed Aslam, Advocate

For Vigilance: Mr. Anil Singh, Advocate

Tags: