Mere Possession Of Another Person's ATM Cards, Cheque Books Without Proof Of Misuse Doesn't Establish Cheating: Rajasthan High Court
The Rajasthan High Court has observed that mere possession of ATM cards and blank cheque books belonging to other persons does not constitute cheating or forgery, in the absence of evidence showing their use for fraudulent transactions.While granting bail to a man accused of cheating and forgery, Justice Praveer Bhatnagar noted that there was no evidence that the accused had withdrawn any...
The Rajasthan High Court has observed that mere possession of ATM cards and blank cheque books belonging to other persons does not constitute cheating or forgery, in the absence of evidence showing their use for fraudulent transactions.
While granting bail to a man accused of cheating and forgery, Justice Praveer Bhatnagar noted that there was no evidence that the accused had withdrawn any money using the four ATM cards allegedly recovered from his possession. The six cheque books recovered from him were also blank and unsigned.
The Court further highlighted "patent illegality" in the investigation and the Investigating Officer's lack of understanding of basic legal requirements. It directed the Rajasthan Director General of Police to initiate a preliminary inquiry into the alleged negligence of the investigating officers and take further action if negligence was established.
The Court was hearing the third bail application of a man who had been charged with cheating, forgery and other offences following the alleged recovery of four ATM cards and six cheque books belonging to different persons.
It was the case of the petitioner that he was in custody since December 12, 2025, and there was no evidence available against him. It was submitted that the cheque books were never used and were unsigned, and no statements were recorded of the alleged owners of the same. Similarly, there was no evidence of the fact that any of the recovered ATM Cards were used by the petitioner.
On the contrary, the state argued that several FIRs were registered against the petitioner in different states, and hence, he should not be released on bail.
After hearing the contentions, the Court considered that there was no evidence of the petitioner having withdrawn any money using the ATM Cards. Similarly, the cheque books were also blank and unsigned.
Hence, the Court concluded that prima facie it appeared that the petitioner was implicated solely based on suspicion arising from the alleged recovery of cheque-books and ATM cards that did not belong to him. The Court observed,
“It is difficult to understand how the Investigating Officer concluded that the petitioner had committed cheating or withdrew money from the relevant accounts, when there is no evidence that he used the ATM cards and no bank statements substantiating any withdrawal. At most, the record suggests that the petitioner may use the cheque books or ATM cards in the future That possibility alone, however, would not constitute cheating or otherwise attract Sections 318(4), 316(2), 338, 336(2), 340(2) of BNS.”
The Court further opined that registration of multiple FIRs against the petitioner, could not by itself justify denying bail, especially when there was no evidence establishing that he cheated anyone using the recovered cheque books and ATM cards.
Furthermore, the Court also flagged out the error committed by the lower courts in dismissing the bail applications, without examining the merits of the case. It stated that the lower courts were expected to examine at-least the foundational facts on which the accused were implicated.
“Furthermore, the investigation suffers from patent illegality and the investigating officer's lack of understanding of basic legal requirements. The Investigating Officer did not ascertain whether the ATM cards recovered from the petitioner's possession had ever been used, nor he recorded the statements of relevant persons. No bank statements were obtained from the banks of the accounts were maintained or kept in the ordinary course of business.”
In this background, the bail application was allowed and opining it to be its duty to flag this to the DGP, the copy of this order was directed to be forwarded to the officer, to initiate a preliminary enquiry against the concerned IO for his alleged negligence.