Click the Play button to listen to article

The Telangana High Court has recently dismissed a criminal revision plea filed by BRS [Bharath Rashtra Samiti] MLA Paadi Koushik Reddy from Huzurabad and another person, wherein they challenged a magistrate court order, permitting the Criminal Investigation Department (CID) to obtain their specimen voice samples.

For context, these samples were sought by the police, to compare them with video recordings allegedly containing derogatory remarks made against the Commissioner of Police, Karimnagar, at a public gathering.

The single judge bench of Justice B.R. Madhusudhan Rao, while dismissing the plea, held that the order directing the accused to give voice samples, which is an interlocutory order, can't be challenged through a revision plea under Sections 438 and 442 of the Bhartiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 (BNSS).

“…An order directing an accused to give voice sample is purely step-in-aid of investigation or procedural interim order[interlocutory order], it does not determine the guilt or innocence of the accused. It does not terminate the criminal proceedings or finally decide the rights of the parties…. In intermediate orders the proceedings would terminate, but if passed in another way, the proceedings would continue. Investigation in the case is still pending and on careful reading of Section 438(2) of BNSS 2023, it states that the powers of revision conferred by sub-section (1) shall not be exercised in relation to any interlocutory order passed in any appeal, inquiry, trial or other proceedings”, the court noted accordingly.

“…At the cost of repetition, the petition filed by the investigating officer itself shows that investigation is still pending in Crime No.30 of 2026…”, the court said further.

On 25.06.2026, an order was passed by the Magistrate against the petitioners to collect their voice samples, who are accused A1 and A2, based on criminal proceedings pursuant to an FIR registered at Huzurabad Police Station.

According to the FIR, on 29.01.2026, the accused allegedly made derogatory and communally provocative remarks against the Police Commissioner. As per the complainant-Sub Inspector, the petitioner-politician and his followers formed an unlawful assembly to disturb the Samakka-Saralamma Jathara (a tribal religious congregation), wrongfully restrained the public, and raised religious comments.

During this incident, the petitioner allegedly made provocative remarks pertaining to the religion of the Commissioner. The police claimed that during investigation, electronic evidence including a pen drive and a mobile phone containing the questioned recordings were sent to the Forensic Science Laboratory (FSL).

In the criminal proceedings, since the accused denied their voices in the produced recordings, the police had sought the court's permission to get specimen voice samples.

The petitioners, before the High Court, argued that the result of the FSL was still awaited to see if those were original or manipulated. Objections were also raised by the petitioners as to the alleged delay of 50 days in sending the devices to FSL, compromised chain of custody etc. The accused also alleged that the prosecution had failed to place on record hash values, device details, or forensic extraction reports for electronic evidence.

The Public Prosecutor for the state submitted that the accused had denied audio and video evidence and evaded questions pertaining to them.

After hearing both sides, the High Court concluded that the revision was not maintainable on such interlocutory orders, relying on Sudhir Chaudhary Etc Vs. State (NCT of Delhi) (2016), and Ritesh Sinha Vs, State of Uttar Pradesh and another(2019)

“The test for determining whether an order under challenge is interlocutory or whether it was passed at an interim stage, the test is whether upholding the objections raised by a party would result in the culmination of the proceedings. An order that substantially affects the rights of the accused or decides certain rights of the parties would not be an interlocutory order ….This Court is of the view that the order passed by the learned Magistrate is not an intermediate order and the contention of the learned counsel for the petitioners that the bar under Section 438(2) of BNSS is not attracted, is negatived….”, the court said.

Accordingly, the court dismissed the petition as not maintainable, without making any remarks about the merits of the matter.


Tags: