The Supreme Court on Friday declined to urgently list an application seeking recall of a two-judge bench decision referring the petitions challenging the Chief Election Commissioner and Election Commissioners(Appointment, Conditions of Service and Term of Office) Act, 2023) to a Constitution Bench.
Advocate Prashant Bhushan mentioned the application before a bench headed by Chief Justice of India Surya Kant, submitting that the plea seeking recall should be placed before the same two-judge bench - comprising Justice Dipankar Datta and Justice Satish Chandra Sharma- which passed the order of reference. The recall application is filed on the ground that Justice Sharma had a conflict of interest as his son was a standing counsel for the Election Commission of India.
Pointing out that Justice Sharma would be retiring at the end of next week, he sought for an urgent listing.
However, the CJI asked Bhushan to raise the issue before the five-judge Constitution Bench when the matter comes up for hearing.
Justice Joymalya Bagchi, who was also part of the CJI-led bench, observed that the five-judge bench could consider the issue concerning the validity of the reference as well.
Bhushan then replied that the reference itself arose because of Justice Sharma's dissent. "If J Sharma had not dissented in this case, then it would not have been referred to the Constitution Bench," he said.
The CJI however observed that Justice Datta had also ultimately agreed to refer the matter.
"My role was only to constitute the bench," the CJI said.
Bhushan reiterated that the recall application should be placed before the original two-judge bench and sought its listing next week, pointing out that the retirement of Justice Sharma could affect the consideration of the recall application. "Recall application should go before them. It may be listed next week," he urged.
"You can raise before the bench when the matter comes. Presiding judge is there in any case," CJI said declining to grant the request for urgent listing.
The application seeks recall of the two-judge bench's decision to refer the issue concerning the appointment of Election Commissioners to a Constitution Bench. The plea raises an objection to Justice Sharma's participation in the proceedings, alleging a conflict of interest arising from his son's appearance as counsel for the Election Commission.