Click the Play button to listen to article

In the Shiv Sena matter, the Supreme Court yesterday asked the Uddhav Thackeray faction to explain the difference between 'dissent' and 'defection' (under 10th Schedule of the Constitution). 

A bench of CJI Surya Kant, Justice Joymalya Bagchi and Justice V Mohana asked Senior Advocate Kapil Sibal, appearing for the Uddhav Thackeray faction, to explain the difference on the next date. The bench conveyed the same after Sibal argued that Eknath Shinde and other splinter MLAs' intention to 'exit' the alliance could not qualify as mere 'dissent'. 

"Next time you need to explain from your point of view that according to you what is dissent and what is defection. This very line - you are saying amounts to defection. They are saying we are continuing to be members of the Shiv Sena, our grievance is only to the alliance with the NCP and Congress. So the bone of contention will be they say that we continue in Shiv Sena, but we have objection against alliance with these 2 political parties", CJI Kant conveyed to Sibal. 

The senior counsel responded that a Constitution Bench of the Court (in Subhash Desai v. Principal Secretary, Government of Maharashtrai) has ruled otherwise. He further highlighted that the Shinde faction later joined hands with NCP leader Ajit Pawar. 

Hearing the submission, Justice Bagchi said, "the idea of defection and dissent has to be seen on the principles and character of the government itself. If there's unitary party government, there's no dispute that it's defection. But if it's a coalition government and I feel that my party will move out of the coalition...". 

"My party is what party? Legislative party. That's the problem!" Sibal countered. 

The CJI then remarked that it was not the question of 'party'. "Their argument is that there is no question of walking out of Shiv Sena. They say they continue to be part of the party, but within party we are raising a voice against the alliance", the Chief Justice said. 

Sibal then submitted that Shinde faction and Thackeray faction could not both be 'Shiv Sena' at the same time and questioned that if the Shinde group was the real Shiv Sena, then what was the Thackeray faction?

He further commented, "As a matter of principle, if this [Shinde group's 'dissent' claim] is accepted, then democracy will always be in jeopardy in a coalition. I will tell your lordships the acts [constituting defection]". 

The hearing will resume on Wednesday. 

The Court is dealing with a petition filed by Uddhav Thackeray challenging the decision of the Election Commission of India to recognize the Shinde faction as the official Shiv Sena and allot it the official party symbol. Another petition filed by UBT faction member Sunil Prabhu challenging the Maharashtra Speaker's refusal to disqualify the MLAs of the Eknath Shinde faction under the 10th Schedule. 

Case : Sunil Prabhu v. Eknath Shinde, SLP(C) No. 1644-1662/2024 (and connected case) 

Previosly -

Shiv Sena Dispute | Dissent Not Defection; Skipping Party Meeting Doesn't Mean Giving Up Membership : Eknath Shinde to Supreme Court

Shiv Sena Row | SC Judgment Didn't Rule Out 'Legislative Majority Test' To Determine Real Party : Shinde To Supreme Court

Uddhav Sena's Disqualification Plea Infructuous After 14th Maharashtra Assembly Term Expired : Shinde To Supreme Court

Shiv Sena Row | Can We Declare Eknath Shinde Disqualified Today? Supreme Court Asks UBT Group

Shiv Sena Row | Supreme Court Questions ECI Using 'Legislative Majority' Test, Asks Why Official Symbol Wasn't Withheld From Both Factions


Tags: