Click the Play button to listen to article

The Calcutta High Court has refused to interfere with murder and attempt to murder charges framed against promoter Md. Wasim alias Wassi in connection with the March 2024 Garden Reach building collapse, which claimed 15 lives and left several others injured.

Justice Chaitali Chatterjee Das dismissed a criminal revision petition filed by Wasim challenging the order of the Additional District and Sessions Judge, Alipore, framing charges against him under Sections 120B, 302, 307 and 427 of the Indian Penal Code.

The petitioner had argued that the prosecution materials did not disclose the requisite intention or knowledge to sustain charges of murder and attempt to murder. He contended that he was merely the financier of the construction, while the day-to-day work was supervised by another co-accused, Abdul Rauf Nizami alias Sheru, who died in the collapse.

Rejecting the plea, the Court observed that the charges could not be altered at the threshold stage, as doing so could substantially restrict the prosecution's ability to establish the gravity of the allegations during trial.

The Court noted that the charge sheet contained specific allegations against Wasim regarding the use of inferior-quality construction materials. Witness statements also allegedly indicated that he had instructed labourers to mix construction materials in disproportionate quantities and use inferior-quality materials while constructing the building's columns.

"More importantly, the petitioner despite possessing no requisite technical qualifications actively involved himself in the construction of the building, which ultimately collapsed, resulting in death 15 persons and injuries to several others," the Court observed.

The Court further noted that the prosecution had brought on record the petitioner's alleged criminal antecedents, including antecedents relating to the commission of murder.

It held that altering the charges to substantially lesser offences at this stage could leave little scope for the prosecution to effectively establish the gravity of the allegations and the role attributed to the petitioner.

"On the contrary, the petitioner cannot be said to have suffered any prejudice, since the charge has been framed in respect of an offence carrying the maximum punishment," the Court said.

The Court clarified that the trial court would have the liberty to determine the petitioner's culpability and the ultimate outcome of the case after proper appreciation of the evidence adduced during trial.

Background

The case arose from the collapse of a five-storey under-construction building at J-506B and J-506C, Azhar Molla Bagan, Garden Reach, on the intervening night of March 17 and 18, 2024. The collapse also severely damaged several adjoining single-storey tiled-roof houses.

According to the prosecution, the building was being developed by Wasim and others without obtaining the requisite sanction from the Kolkata Municipal Corporation (KMC).

An investigation revealed that the construction had commenced in December 2022 on a plot measuring approximately three cottahs. The building was intended to accommodate four two-bedroom flats on each floor.

An expert team from Jadavpur University examined samples of debris, concrete and iron rods. Its interim report indicated that the quality of the concrete was doubtful, the dimensions of the columns were below the minimum recommended standards under the relevant IS code, and the steel samples did not meet the required yield and ultimate strength standards.

The police registered a case at Garden Reach Police Station under Sections 302, 307, 288, 427 and 34 of the IPC. Following investigation, a charge sheet was submitted against Wasim and five others, also invoking Section 120B IPC.

The trial court subsequently framed charges against the accused, prompting Wasim to approach the High Court.

The petitioner had also challenged the procedure adopted while framing the charges, alleging that the prosecution had not properly opened its case under Section 226 of the Code of Criminal Procedure and that the trial court had proceeded on the basis of a draft charge without providing an adequate opportunity of hearing.

The High Court rejected these contentions, noting that the trial court had considered the materials and case diary in the presence of both prosecution and defence counsel. It also observed that no objection had been raised by the petitioner at that stage and no application seeking discharge or a direction to the prosecution to open its case had been filed.

Accordingly, the Court dismissed the revision petition and declined to interfere with the charges.

Tags: