Click the Play button to listen to article

The Calcutta High Court has refused to interfere with the dismissal of a former State Bank of India (SBI) employee who was found guilty of five out of six charges relating to alleged irregularities in handling customers' accounts and financial transactions.

Justice Partha Sarathi Chatterjee dismissed a writ petition filed by Prasanta Biswas, a former Customer Assistant at SBI's Bally Durgapur Branch, challenging the departmental enquiry report and the subsequent orders of the Disciplinary Authority and Appellate Authority removing him from service.

The petitioner had contended that the allegations against him, at best, constituted procedural irregularities and negligence, and that the Bank had suffered no financial loss. He also challenged the disciplinary proceedings on grounds of violation of natural justice, non-supply of relevant documents, and disproportionate punishment.

Rejecting the contention that subsequent refunds and the absence of financial loss could absolve the employee of misconduct, the Court observed that a bank employee was required to follow prescribed procedures while handling customers' accounts, irrespective of whether the Bank ultimately suffered monetary loss.

"A subsequent refund or regularisation of an irregular transaction may make good the financial loss, but it does not, by itself, erase the misconduct already committed," the Court held.

The Court further observed that the allegations did not concern isolated acts of inadvertence or occasional lapses in the discharge of official duties.

"Taken cumulatively, the charges concern repeated instances of unauthorised handling of customers' accounts, effecting debit entries without requisite authority, disbursing money without proper verification of the account holder's signature and failure to credit a customer's deposit until a complaint was lodged with the Bank," the judgment stated.

It added that such conduct, if established, struck at the foundation of the trust and confidence reposed in a bank employee entrusted with handling customers' money.

The Court also rejected the employee's challenge to the reference to Clause 7(c) of the Memorandum of Settlement (MoS) in the charge-sheet, which deals with minor misconduct, when the disciplinary proceedings were conducted for major misconduct under Clause 5(j).

The Bank had argued that the reference to Clause 7(c) was an inadvertent error and that the allegations had throughout been treated as major misconduct.

Accepting the Bank's contention, the Court observed that the charge-sheet expressly described the alleged acts as major misconduct and detailed the individual transactions, their dates, amounts and the manner in which the petitioner was alleged to have acted.

"On a reading of the charge-sheet as a whole, it is evident that the petitioner was made aware of the allegations constituting major misconduct and was afforded an opportunity to defend himself," the Court observed.

It held that the mere erroneous reference to Clause 7(c), instead of Clause 5(j), would not vitiate the disciplinary proceedings, particularly when the petitioner had failed to demonstrate any real prejudice to his defence.

The Court also found no sufficient ground to interfere with the findings of the Enquiry Officer, who had held five of the six charges proved, or with the orders passed by the Disciplinary and Appellate Authorities.

On the question of proportionality, the Court held that the penalty of removal from service could not be considered shockingly disproportionate merely because the amounts had subsequently been refunded or the Bank had ultimately suffered no financial loss.

The petitioner was serving as a Customer Assistant at SBI's Bally Durgapur Branch when several alleged irregularities came to light concerning transactions undertaken between April 2013 and January 2014.

One of the allegations concerned a double debit of Rs. 1,000 from a customer's account on September 2, 2013, although only Rs. 1,000 had been disbursed to the customer. The petitioner claimed that he had subsequently deposited the excess amount into the customer's account.

Other charges concerned an alleged unauthorised transfer of Rs. 7,000 from his father's account, disbursement of Rs. 6,000 against a withdrawal slip without proper signature verification, an alleged unauthorised debit of Rs. 60,000 from a customer's account and failure to credit a customer's deposit of Rs. 6,000.

The Bank issued a charge-sheet on April 23, 2015, containing six articles of charge. The petitioner denied the allegations and claimed that the transactions had either been rectified or were supported by explanations and subsequent confirmations.

Following a departmental enquiry, the Enquiry Officer held five of the six charges proved, with only the charge concerning the Rs. 7,000 transaction being found unestablished.

The Disciplinary Authority subsequently imposed the penalty of removal from service without disqualification for future employment on December 5, 2015. The Appellate Authority upheld the punishment on March 17, 2016.

Challenging the disciplinary proceedings, Biswas approached the High Court seeking reinstatement with consequential benefits, including back wages.

The High Court, however, found no sufficient ground to interfere with the disciplinary proceedings or the penalty imposed and dismissed the writ petition.

Tags: