Mere Online Accessibility Of Judicial Order Can't Confer Territorial Jurisdiction To Hear De-Indexing Plea: Delhi High Court
The Delhi High Court has held that the mere accessibility of a digitised judicial order on the internet in a particular State cannot confer territorial jurisdiction on the High Court of that State to entertain a plea seeking its de-indexing from online search results.
Justice Swarana Kanta Sharma observed that once a judicial order is uploaded on the internet, it becomes equally accessible across the country and even the world.
“If the mere accessibility of a digitised judicial record at a particular place were to be treated as an integral part of the cause of action, every High Court in the country would possess the jurisdiction to entertain a petition seeking de-indexing of a judicial record of any other Court, irrespective of where the proceedings were conducted or where the record was created,” the Court said.
“Such an interpretation would render the requirement of the cause of action arising “wholly or in part” within the territories of a High Court under Article 226(2) of the Constitution otiose, and would also encourage forum shopping,” it added.
The Court made the observation while dismissing a plea filed by Dr Aman Tuli, a practising doctor, seeking removal of a 2019 bail order from Google search results and disabling of name-based search functionality in respect of the order on Indian Kanoon.
Tuli had sought de-indexing of a bail order dated September 27, 2019, passed by the Gauhati High Court in criminal proceedings against him.
He submitted that despite having been discharged in the case, the bail order continued to appear whenever his name was searched on Google, affecting his reputation.
He was booked in an FIR registered at Sonari Police Station in Assam on September 17, 2019, for offences under Sections 493, 496 and 376 of the Indian Penal Code. He was arrested the following day and subsequently granted bail by the Gauhati High Court.
A chargesheet was later filed against him only under Section 498A of IPC. However, the Judicial Magistrate First Class, Sonari, discharged him on January 8, 2021, holding that the charge against him was groundless. The discharge order attained finality as it was not challenged.
Before the Court, Tuli argued that he was entitled to de-indexing in view of his discharge and relied on the Court's earlier judgment in Laksh Vir Singh Yadav v. Union of India, which laid down guidelines governing de-indexing, de-linking and masking of judicial records in cases of acquittal or discharge.
The authorities, however, raised a preliminary objection regarding territorial jurisdiction, contending that the bail order sought to be de-indexed was passed by the Gauhati High Court and the entire criminal proceedings, from registration of the FIR to the petitioner's discharge, had taken place in Assam.
The Court examined Article 226(2) of the Constitution of India and noted that the only averment made by Tuli to establish territorial jurisdiction was that he was a resident of Delhi.
It held that the Tuli's residence in the national capital was not a material or integral part of the cause of action and could not, by itself, confer territorial jurisdiction on the Delhi High Court.
The Court also distinguished its earlier decision in Kokkanti Venkata Maheswara Reddy v. Google LLC, relied upon by Tuli.
It noted that the earlier case concerned online news reports published by national media houses and accessible to readers across the country. Further, it noted that Google LLC, the concerned YouTube grievance officer and the Union Ministry of Electronics and Information Technology were situated within the territorial jurisdiction of the Delhi High Court in that case.
In the present case, it said, the grievance concerned only a judicial order passed by the Gauhati High Court and reproduced on Indian Kanoon.
The Court also noted that Google LLC was based in California, USA, while Google India Private Limited was based in Bengaluru, and that Tuli had not issued any prior notice or representation to the respondents seeking de-indexing.
Invoking the doctrine of forum conveniens, the Court observed that any direction regulating the manner in which a judicial record of the Gauhati High Court is accessed or searched would be most appropriately examined by that Court itself.
“Even otherwise, this Court is of the view that the High Court of Gauhati is the forum conveniens for adjudication of the grievance raised by the petitioner,” the Court said.
Accordingly, the Court dismissed the plea on the ground of lack of territorial jurisdiction, leaving it open to Tuli to avail remedies available in law, including approaching the Gauhati High Court.
The Court clarified that it had not expressed any opinion on the merits of the case.