The Delhi High Court has reiterated that an Aadhaar card is not, by itself, proof of date of birth, while upholding a Labour Court's decision granting back wages to a woman worker whose services were illegally terminated by her employer on the ground that she had attained the age of retirement.
Justice Manoj Kumar Ohri observed that Aadhaar is primarily proof of identity and that where conflicting records regarding a person's age are available, their relative evidentiary value must be assessed.
"However, an Aadhaar card is not, by itself, proof of date of birth. The Office Memorandum dated 20.12.2018 issued by UIDAI, which has been placed on record by the workwoman, clarifies the said position," the Court observed.
The Court noted that the UIDAI memorandum stated that dates of birth are recorded on the basis of documents or self-declarations furnished by Aadhaar cardholders. It further clarified that the Aadhaar Act, 2016 recognises Aadhaar as proof of identity but not as proof of date of birth.
The Court also relied on the Supreme Court's decision in Saroj v. IFFCO-Tokio General Insurance Co., which held that an Aadhaar card, though usable to establish identity, is not per se proof of date of birth.
The observations were made while dismissing a petition filed by M/s J.J. Electronics against a Labour Court award in favour of its former employee, Rosamma Joy.
The workwoman claimed that she had been employed with the establishment since December 1981 and was earning ₹10,500 per month. She alleged that after she demanded revised minimum wages, her services were terminated on May 20, 2017.
The management however maintained that she had attained the age of superannuation of 58 years on that date, as her Aadhaar card recorded her date of birth as May 20, 1959. It also claimed that she had voluntarily retired after undergoing cataract surgery.
The Labour Court rejected the management's contentions, noting that the employer itself had furnished her date of birth as May 20, 1960, to the Employees' State Insurance Corporation (ESIC) at the time of her registration in 2010.
It consequently held her termination to be illegal and awarded full back wages from May 20, 2017, to May 20, 2018, when she would have attained the retirement age.
Before the High Court, the management argued that the Labour Court had erred in disregarding the Aadhaar card relied upon by the workwoman herself.
However, the High Court observed that the burden of proving superannuation rested upon the management, which had relied solely on the Aadhaar card without producing any other document establishing her date of birth.
The Court noted that the ESIC record was prepared several years before the dispute arose, when neither party had any apparent reason to contest the workwoman's age.
It also found that the management had neither cross-examined the ESIC official who proved the record nor produced the documents on the basis of which it had originally furnished the employee's date of birth.
"Having recorded her date of birth as 20.05.1960, the management could not later rely upon a different date in an Aadhaar card to end her services a year earlier. It is also worth mentioning at this point that the ID Act is a beneficial piece of legislation," the Court observed.
It held that the Labour Court had rightly preferred the earlier ESIC record over the Aadhaar card and that its finding was based on evidence and did not warrant interference under writ jurisdiction.
As such, the Court dismissed the employer's petition.
For Petitioner: Ms. Renu, Mr. Kamlesh Kumar Mishra, Mr. Piyush, and Ms. Mansi, Advocates
For Respondent: Mr. Aarlin Moncy and Ms. Sruti Mehrotra, Advocates