Life Insurance Policy Lapses If Premium Not Paid Within Grace Period: Gauhati High Court Quashes Rs 4 Lakh Ombudsman Award
The Gauhati High Court has set aside an Insurance Ombudsman's award directing LIC to pay Rs 4 lakh to the nominee of a policyholder who died 13 days after the expiry of the grace period for payment of premium.
Justice Devashis Baruah, observed, "In the instant case, the proposition of law laid down by the Supreme Court squarely applies. Accordingly, it is the opinion of this Court that the impugned Award dated 05.08.2022 passed by the respondent No. 1 directing the petitioner to pay the sum assured as well as the accidental benefit under a lapsed policy is contrary to the policy conditions and is, therefore, liable to be interfered with."
The observation came in a writ petition filed by the Life Insurance Corporation of India (LIC) challenging a 2022 award, passed by the Insurance Ombudsman, directing it to pay Rs 2 lakh as the sum assured and Rs 2 lakh as accidental benefit to the nominee of a deceased policyholder.
The case concerned a policy obtained by Hari Prasad Adhikary, which commenced in 2018. The monthly premium was Rs 1,400, including GST, and premiums for 28 months had been paid. However, the premium due in 2020, was dishonoured in the same year due to insufficient balance.
Adhikary died in a road accident in December, 2020. His wife, submitted a claim which LIC repudiated in March, 2022, on the ground that the policy was in a lapsed condition at the time of his death.
The High Court examined Clause 2 of the policy conditions, which provided a grace period of 15 days for payment of monthly premiums.
The Court observed, "From a perusal of the above quoted clause, it would be seen that a grace period of one month, but not less than 30 days is provided for yearly, half-yearly and quarterly modes of premium payment and 15 days for the monthly mode of premium payment. It is also mentioned that if the premium is not paid before the expiry of the grace period, the policy lapses."
The Court noted that the 29th premium fell due on November 18, 2020, and was dishonoured on November 23, 2020. There was no subsequent attempt to make the payment within December, 2020, which was the expiry of the 15-day grace period.
The Court noted that the issue in the present case was well settled by the Supreme Court in *Life Insurance Corporation of India v. Mani Ram*, (2005) 6 SCC 274, and that the proposition of law laid down therein squarely applied to the instant case.
The Court recorded, "The Policy bearing No. 403121414 had lapsed on account of non-payment of the premium by 03.12.2020."
It further noted, "Late Hari Prasad Adhikary expired on 16.12.2020, when Policy No. 403121414 was in a lapsed condition."
Accordingly, the Court held, "The impugned Award dated 05.08.2022 directing the petitioner to pay the sum assured along with the accidental benefit is contrary to the policy conditions and the settled principles of law. Accordingly, the impugned Award dated 05.08.2022 is set aside and quashed."
The writ petition was accordingly disposed of with no order as to costs.
Case Title: Life Insurance Corporation of India v. The Insurance Ombudsman and 2 Ors.
Case No.: WP(C)/135/2023