Rajasthan High Court Restores Rule Requiring Lawyers To Show Proof Of Two Court Appearances To Vote In Bar Association Elections
The Rajasthan High Court has upheld and restored two additional eligibility conditions introduced by the Election Committee of Rajasthan High Court Bar Association, for the upcoming elections, for being a voter, opining that the conditions were a bona fide attempt to ensure that the elections represent advocates who were actually engaged in active legal practice.As per the notices issued by...
The Rajasthan High Court has upheld and restored two additional eligibility conditions introduced by the Election Committee of Rajasthan High Court Bar Association, for the upcoming elections, for being a voter, opining that the conditions were a bona fide attempt to ensure that the elections represent advocates who were actually engaged in active legal practice.
As per the notices issued by the Election Committee, it was notified that only those members of Rajasthan High Court Bar Association shall be eligible to vote, who either possessed order sheets of atleast two appearances for the Jaipur bench of the Court, or had copies of two vakalatnamas.
These notices were eventually withdrawn by a subsequent notice issued by the Election Committee, and in this background, the present petition was filed by a senior member of Rajasthan High Court Bar Association.
While raising concern regarding the upliftment of standard of the Bar and election reforms, the petition sought upholding of the conditions that were introduced by the Election Committee.
After hearing the contentions, the Court opined that the conditions were introduced as a reasonable and objectively verifiable indicator of professional activity, to ensure that electoral process was represented by advocates who were actually engaged in active legal practice.
The Court observed that since Election Committee was responsible for conducting free, fair and meaningful elections, it was competent to prescribe reasonable regulatory measures to ensure that the electorate comprises of genuinely active members.
In this regard, the Court also clarified that it was true that Election Committee did not have power to amend or override the Byelaws, that already prescribe eligibility criteria to vote in elections. However, a reasonable regulatory condition, intended at verifying the professional engagement, could not be treated as an amendment of the Bye Laws.
“The eligibility conditions prescribed under the Bye-laws are required to be construed as laying down the minimum requirements for participation in the electoral process. Unless the Bye-laws expressly prohibit the prescription of additional reasonable regulatory requirements, the Election Committee cannot be rendered powerless to adopt appropriate measures for ensuring that the voters' list comprises members who are genuinely engaged in active practice. The authority to conduct elections necessarily carries with it the incidental power to prescribe reasonable modalities for verification of the eligibility of voters, provided such measures are not inconsistent with the Bye laws or otherwise arbitrary.”
The Court further stated that bar association was not merely an association of persons holding membership by virtue of their enrolment as advocates. It was a body representing the collective interests and professional concerns of advocates. Hence, the electoral process should reflect the participation of advocates who had an actual and continuing professional connection with the Court.
It was further highlighted by the Court that membership of a Bar Association and eligibility to participate in elections, were two different concepts, wherein a person might continue to remain a member, but right to participate could be regulated by reasonable conditions having rational nexus with the objects and institutional character of the association.
In this background, the Court observed,
“The condition is neither onerous nor excessive. It provides two alternative modes of establishing professional engagement and is founded upon objective and verifiable documentary material. The requirement is not intended to assess the professional competence or standing of an advocate but merely to ascertain whether the member has remained professionally connected with the Court during the relevant period.”
Accordingly, the petition was allowed and the conditions introduced by the Election Committee were upheld.