Motor Accident Claim Can Be Amended To Remove Clerical Errors, But Can't Introduce New Sequence Of Events: Telangana High Court
The Telangana High Court dismissed a batch of pleas challenging orders of the Motor Accident Claims Tribunal which had rejected applications seeking amendment of accident claim petitions at the stage of cross-examination of the respondent witness.
The single judge bench of Justice J. Sreenivas Rao opined that the proposed amendments were not intended to rectify any inadvertent mistake, clerical error or procedural irregularity.
According to the court, it sought to introduce a novel, different version of the accident by shifting the allegation of rash and negligent driving from the driver of a Maruthi WagonR car[accused in the FIR] to the driver of a Mahindra Xylo car.
“petitioners are not seeking to rectify any inadvertent mistake, clerical error or procedural irregularity in the original claim petitions…it is evident that the proposed amendments are not merely intended to clarify or explain the existing pleadings… On the contrary, the petitioners are seeking to introduce an entirely different version of the accident by shifting the allegation of rash and negligent driving from the driver of the Maruthi Wagonr Car to respondent No.4 and by introducing a new sequence of events concerning the manner in which the accident occurred….”, the court noted while dismissing the plea.
About shifting the allegation of rash and negligent driving from the WagonR driver to the Mahindra Xylo driver, the court opined that it would irretrievably change the character of the claim petitions.
To recap, the petitioners had filed multiple claim petitions arising out of an accident in 2018.
According to the original pleadings, the injured petitioners, along with their deceased father and mother, were travelling in a WagonR enroute Mangalore. As per the plea, the driver of the WagonR rode rashly and negligently, as a result of which the WagonR collided with a Xylo. Claim petitions then came to be filed for the death of their relatives as well as for the injuries sustained by the petitioners themselves in the accident.
After this, applications were filed to amend the claim petitions, saying that their counsels were not properly instructed about how the Xylo Car came from the wrong side, thereby causing the accident. The driver, accused in the original pleadings, was said to have taken all precautions to avoid the accident, which the original petitioners came to know later, as per the applications.
These applications were dismissed by the court citing that the plea had reached the stage of cross examination of RW-2.
Adv. N. V. R. Rajya Lakshmi appeared for the petitioners, and argued that respondent No. 4 was the [owner and driver of the Mahindra Xylo] who was actually involved in the rash driving, and hence liable. It was also contended that amendments necessary for determining the real questions in controversy should be permitted despite any delay.
Adv. A. Rama Krishna Reddy opposed the plea and pointed out that the FIR was registered based on the complaint of R4-Xylo driver, and that the Investigating Officer filed a final report against the WagonR driver.
.At the stage of cross-examination of RW.2, the petitioners sought to introduce a new plea that the accident had occurred due to the rash and negligent driving of respondent No. 4, who was allegedly proceeding on the wrong side of the road, the court inferred.
After hearing both sides, the court noted as below by relying on Revajeetu Builders and Developers v. Narayanaswamy and sons and others [2009]:
“…The Hon'ble Supreme Court categorically observed that the Court must examine whether the proposed amendment is imperative for proper and effective adjudication of the case, whether the application is bona fide or mala fide, whether the amendment causes prejudice to the opposite party, and more particularly, whether the proposed amendment fundamentally changes the nature and character of the case…”
It was also iterated by the court that the parties could not seek amendment of the pleadings at the trial stage, without showing that they exhibited due diligence under the proviso of Order VI rule 17 of the C.P.C, and despite that, the parties were not able to bring a specific fact to the attention of court prior to that.
Accordingly, all the civil revision petitions were dismissed.