Click the Play button to listen to article

The Supreme Court on Friday issued limited notice to the Union Government on a public interest litigation highlighting the potential medical risks associated with consanguineous marriages and seeking measures to create greater public awareness about their possible consequences.

The Court issued notice for the limited purpose of impressing upon the Union of India to consider the desirability of suitable legislation, or to ensure wide publicity through different channels, including a proper curriculum in schools and colleges, to instil scientific temper towards the negative impacts of consanguineous marriages.

A bench comprising Chief Justice of India Surya Kant, Justice Joymalya Bagchi and Justice V Mohana was hearing a Public Interest Litigation filed by Charvi S., a 20-year-old law student with 40% visual impairment, who sought measures to address the health risks associated with marriages between close blood relatives.

Senior Advocate Kaadambari Singh appeared for the petitioner.

During the hearing, the bench observed that most of the reliefs were in the legislative domain; however, it agreed that it was a matter requiring public awareness, though marriage was a matter of personal choice.

Justice Bagchi observed that the Courts have earlier recognised the right of a person to marry an HIV-infected person with knowledge. However, Justice Bagchi agreed that the persons should be able to take an "informed decision" regarding consanguine marriages.

The petitioner's counsel submitted that the practice was mostly prevalent in rural areas, where awareness was limited. "At least people should be apprised of the adverse consequences through wide publicity and some structured information system," Singh submitted.

Details of the petition

The petition, filed under Article 32 of the Constitution, was filed by a law student at the National Law School of India University, Bengaluru. She is herself an offspring of a first-cousin marriage.

According to the petition, her parents are first cousins who married in accordance with longstanding traditions prevalent in their Reddy community. The petition states that they were unaware of the potential medical consequences associated with such a marriage.

The petitioner was diagnosed with cone dystrophy, an inherited eye disorder, and has 40% visual impairment. Her medical records document nystagmus (involuntary eye movements) from birth, photophobia (sensitivity to light) and severely diminished cone responses in electrophysiological tests.

The petition states that her condition has affected several aspects of her daily life, including her ability to distinguish colours, cross roads independently and perform routine activities. It also recounts the difficulties she faced during childhood, including disruptions to her education because some schools were unable to accommodate her medical requirements.

Relying on her personal experience and medical literature, the petitioner argued that the State has a constitutional obligation to prevent foreseeable genetic harm to future generations.

The petition, however, clarified that its immediate objective was not to criminalise existing marriages or retrospectively unsettle their legal status.

Challenge to marriage law provisions

The PIL questioned the statutory exceptions permitting marriages within prohibited degrees of relationship on the basis of customary practices.

It specifically challenged Sections 5(iv) and 5(v) of the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955, and Section 4(d) of the Special Marriage Act, 1954.

Section 5(iv) of the Hindu Marriage Act permits marriages between persons within prohibited degrees of relationship where the custom or usage governing each of them permits such a marriage. Section 5(v) similarly provides an exception for marriages between sapindas where the applicable custom permits it.

Section 4(d) of the Special Marriage Act also contains an exception permitting marriages within prohibited degrees of relationship where a custom governing at least one of the parties allows such a union.

The petitioner argued that these customary exceptions are constitutionally problematic because they permit close-kin marriages despite medical evidence indicating an increased risk of genetic disorders and congenital conditions among their offspring.

The challenge was founded primarily on Articles 14 and 21, read with the State's public health obligations under Article 47. The petitioner contended that permitting such unions without adequate safeguards compromises the rights of children to health, dignity, bodily integrity and full development.

The petition also invoked Article 15(3), which enables the State to make special provisions for women and children, and referred to Article 25(2)(b) in support of legislative intervention for social reform.

Petition cites 11% national prevalence, higher rates in southern states

Citing the National Family Health Survey-5 (2019-21), the petition stated that consanguineous marriages account for approximately 11% of marriages nationally.

It further relied on research indicating that the prevalence is considerably higher in parts of southern India, with estimates ranging between 23% and 28%.

The petition referred to traditional kinship practices involving cross-cousin marriages and maternal uncle-niece unions in certain communities in southern India. It argued that such practices have historically been accepted as customary forms of marriage.

The petition relied on several medical studies to support its arguments regarding adverse health effects. It cited research indicating that children born to first-cousin parents may face approximately twice the risk of congenital birth defects compared to children born to unrelated parents.

It also referred to studies associating consanguinity with increased homozygosity, which raises the likelihood of recessive genetic conditions being expressed in offspring.

The medical literature cited in the petition discusses possible associations with congenital anomalies, sensory impairments, developmental disabilities, reproductive complications and increased infant morbidity and mortality.

Reliefs sought

The PIL sought a declaration that the statutory exceptions permitting consanguineous marriages are unconstitutional, or alternatively, directions for introducing appropriate safeguards.

A direction to reconsider the provisions of the Hindu Marriage Act and the Special Marriage Act permitting consanguineous marriages on customary grounds, with a view to introducing safeguards or a comprehensive statutory prohibition.

Mandatory premarital genetic counselling and voluntary genetic screening in districts and regions with a high prevalence of such marriages.

A comprehensive nationwide public awareness campaign through print, electronic, digital and community-based media.

Phased interim measures aimed at the gradual curtailment or elimination of the practice.

Importantly, the petitioner specifically sought clarification that any preventive and regulatory measures should not criminalise existing marriages or retrospectively disturb their legal status.

 The petition was filed through Anjuman Tripathy AoR.

Tags: