Police Can't Justify Restraint Of Journalists By Merely Avoiding Words 'Arrest' Or 'Detention': Media Organisation Tells Supreme Court
| Journalism cannot be made conditional on accreditation, the Network of Women in Media stated in the rejoinder.
The Network of Women in Media, India (NWMI) has told the Supreme Court that the police cannot justify interference with personal liberty simply by refraining from describing their actions as arrest or detention, arguing that the legality of police action must be assessed by its actual effect rather than the terminology used to characterise it.
" The police cannot justify an interference with personal liberty simply by refraining from calling it a detention or arrest," the organisation submitted in a rejoinder filed before the Supreme Court on November 21, challenging the Delhi Police's counter-affidavit in a petition concerning the alleged detention, forcible removal and harassment of journalists covering the anti-CEC protests in Delhi in October.
NWMI argued that the Delhi Police's own admissions that journalists were apprehended, removed from protest sites, placed in police vehicles for verification and subsequently released establish the interference with their personal liberty and professional work.
The organisation contended that describing these actions as 'removal for verification', 'crowd control', 'mistaken identity' or 'bona fide error' does not establish the legal authority for restraining journalists.
"The substance and effect of the restraint must satisfy Articles 14, 19, 21 and, wherever attracted, Article 22 of the Constitution," the rejoinder states.
It further argued that the police had failed to disclose the specific legal authority, directions issued, officers involved and contemporaneous records justifying the restraint of individual journalists.
Referring to Sections 172(1) and 172(2) of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita (BNSS), NWMI submitted that the police could invoke the power to require compliance with lawful directions only after satisfying the statutory conditions. Similarly, Section 65 of the Delhi Police Act requires a reasonable direction issued in the discharge of official duty and resistance, refusal or failure to comply with it.
The rejoinder states that the police have not identified, incident-wise, the directions allegedly issued, the officers who issued them, the conduct constituting disobedience or why removal was necessary instead of adopting less restrictive measures.
Relying on the Supreme Court's judgment in D.K. Basu v. State of West Bengal, NWMI argued that arrest and detention are subject to safeguards, including identification of police personnel, maintenance of contemporaneous records and communication of custody to the persons concerned.
The organisation maintained that the police cannot circumvent these safeguards by avoiding the formal description of their actions as arrest or detention.
The petition, filed under Article 32 of the Constitution, seeks protection of journalists, particularly women journalists, against arbitrary obstruction, forcible removal, detention, assault and sexual harassment while undertaking newsgathering.
NWMI pointed out that the police counter-affidavit contradicts its categorical denial of interference with journalists by acknowledging that persons, including journalists, were removed from protest sites and subsequently released after their identities were established.
It argued that the eventual release of journalists does not answer the legality of their initial restraint or transportation.
The rejoinder also refers to the Supreme Court's October 11, 2026 order in contempt proceedings, which directed that lawyers, journalists and other professionals should not be obstructed or hindered in discharging their professional duties.
According to NWMI, the police could have adopted less restrictive arrangements during the pre-planned protests, including designated press areas, liaison officers, safe access and exit routes and protective equipment wherever necessary.
Journalism cannot be made conditional on accreditation
NWMI has also challenged the Delhi Police's attempt to distinguish professional journalists from individuals described as 'reel-makers'.
It argued that the freedom to gather and report news cannot be made conditional upon accreditation, formal employment with a recognised media organisation or possession of an employer-issued identity card.
Independent journalists, freelancers and digital journalists are also entitled to undertake lawful newsgathering from public places, it submitted.
The rejoinder points out that the police themselves have acknowledged that journalists cannot be denied the right to gather news merely because they do not possess Press Information Bureau accreditation or an employer-issued identity card.
Disputing the use of the term 'reel-makers', NWMI said reels are simply a format for recording and disseminating information, which is also used by established news organisations and government agencies.
"What matters is what the person was doing: recording police action at a public protest for publication is newsgathering and dissemination, irrespective of the duration, format or platform employed," it stated.
It further argued that Article 19(1)(a) protects freedom of speech and expression irrespective of the medium used.
Police handling of women journalists and sexual harassment complaints
The rejoinder also raises concerns over the physical handling of women journalists by male police personnel during the protests.
NWMI pointed out that the police counter-affidavit acknowledges four complaints alleging sexual harassment of women journalists arising from the events of October 3, 2026. The complaints were subsequently closed by the Crime Branch.
The organisation argued that the closure of complaints within the same police establishment whose personnel are accused of misconduct reinforces the need for an independent inquiry.
It also referred to the National Human Rights Commission taking suo motu cognisance on October 8, 2026, of reported harassment of three women journalists and issuing notice to the Delhi Police Commissioner.
The rejoinder disputes the police's reliance on the complainants' alleged reluctance to pursue complaints, their non-participation in the inquiry and the absence of the alleged acts in available CCTV footage.
It argued that a complainant's decision not to pursue a police inquiry cannot be treated as conclusive proof that the alleged incident did not occur.
NWMI also challenged the police's attempt to justify intervention by male officers by distinguishing between crowd control and arrest or search.
It relied on Sections 43, 46 and 49 of the BNSS, which provide safeguards concerning the arrest, restraint and search of women.
The organisation argued that where dragging, lifting, carrying, confinement in a police vehicle or transportation effectively amounts to arrest or custodial apprehension, the police cannot avoid statutory safeguards by describing the action as crowd control or removal.
Specific incidents of journalists being removed
The rejoinder also responds to the police's explanations concerning individual journalists named in the petition.
It refers to the alleged removal of journalists Shashwat, Siya and Vijay of The Indian Express Hindi from Connaught Place to Chhatrasal Stadium, approximately 12 kilometres away, despite their displaying press identification. They were reportedly released around 45 minutes later.
Another incident concerns Anushka Bharadwaj of Business Standard, who was allegedly dragged by her clothes on October 10 despite identifying herself as a journalist.
The rejoinder also refers to Nidhi Suresh of The News Minute, who was allegedly detained at around 3 pm on October 11, with a subsequent communication stating that the detained women were informed around 6.30 pm that they could leave.
It further questions the police's description of the removal of Ryan Thomas of The Caravan as a mere removal, pointing out that the counter-affidavit acknowledges the existence of a medico-legal record while declining to disclose medical details on the ground that the matter remains under investigation.
NWMI also refers to the alleged restraint of Shoaib Daniyal of Scroll, who was reportedly searched while waiting for a taxi in South Delhi, approximately 21 kilometres from Jantar Mantar. His identity document was allegedly photographed, he was taken in a police vehicle and was asked to delete recordings before being released around 90 minutes later.
The organisation argued that the police had failed to provide incident-specific explanations or identify the officers responsible for the alleged actions.