Click the Play button to listen to article

The Allahabad High Court has questioned the Uttar Pradesh authorities over the continued registration of FIRs under the UP Gangsters and Anti-Social Activities (Prevention) Act, 1986, despite the Supreme Court having declared the Act 'stillborn'.

"Once the law with regard to the Act, 1986, has been enunciated by the Apex Court in August, 2026, consequently, there cannot be any occasion for the authorities to continue with the registration of First Information Reports under the provisions of the Act, 1986", a Bench of Justice Abdul Moin and Justice Pramod Kumar Srivastava observed.

The Court added that it is not expected to repeatedly point out the 'inaction' on the part of the authorities in not adhering to the judgments of the Apex Court.

The Court further directed the Additional Chief Secretary (Home), Uttar Pradesh, to file a personal affidavit explaining why FIRs under the Act are still being registered, what action is proposed against the authorities responsible and what remedial measures are to be taken.

Briefly put, the Court was hearing a writ petition filed by Brijesh Kumar alias Banty Verma challenging an FIR registered last month under Section 3(1) of the Gangsters Act at Akbarpur Police Station in Ambedkar Nagar district.

The petitioner's counsel referred to the Supreme Court's August 2026 judgment in Shiv Pratap Singh alias Chinu v. State of U.P. and Others, wherein the 1986 Act was declared 'stillborn'.

Consequently, it was argued that the authorities could not continue investigating the FIR registered under its provisions. The State's counsel did not dispute this submission.

Taking note of the Supreme Court ruling, the High Court, at the ot directed that the operation of the impugned FIR would remain stayed until further orders and that no further proceedings would be undertaken in pursuance of it.

The Bench then expressed concern that, despite the Supreme Court judgment, the impugned FIR had been registered on October 23, 2026.

The Court added that the authorities' insistence on registering such FIRs, despite the Supreme Court ruling, forced litigants to approach the High Court and thereby wasted the "precious judicial time of the Constitutional Court".

The Bench also noted that Additional Government Advocates had earlier been apprised of the registration of FIRs despite the Supreme Court judgment, but "it appears that no heed has been paid to the same".

In view of these circumstances, the Court required the Additional Chief Secretary (Home) to file his personal affidavit within 3 weeks.

The Court further directed that, if the affidavit was not filed, the ACS (Home) would have to appear in person along with the relevant records to assist the Court.

The matter has been listed for December 15.

Importantly, another division bench of the High Court on November 19 held that the 1986 Act remains operative despite the Supreme Court's recent observation declaring the Act 'stillborn'.

The High Court clarified that the Supreme Court had not declared the Act unconstitutional and that an earlier Full Bench judgment of the HC in Ashok Kumar Dixit vs State Of U.P. And Anr. 1989 upholding its validity continued to bind it. 

Last month, a Single Judge sought a response from the Uttar Pradesh Government on the Supreme Court's 'stillborn' observation regarding the 1986 Act.

Tags: