Click the Play button to listen to article

The Supreme Court today refused to entertain a plea seeking a structured database of complainants who lodge multiple sexual-offence cases. Underlining the need to protect identity of victims/complainants, as well as referring to existing identification mechanisms, the Court dismissed the plea. 

A bench of CJI Surya Kant, Justice Joymalya Bagchi and Justice V Mohana was dealing with a challenge to the Delhi High Court order which disposed of the petitioner's PIL seeking similar relief. The High Court had directed the Delhi Police and other authorities to expeditiously decide the petitioner's representation seeking such a database. 

During the hearing, the petitioner's counsel urged that the petitioner was seeking such a database at police headquarters in every district.

Justice Bagchi remarked that such a database could serve as a "gateway to the disclosure of identity (of victims)". The judge further noted that a 2-layer identification mechanism is already in place for sexual offense cases, as (i) the law requires medical examination of a victim (including DNA profiling), (ii) the statement of a victim is recorded before a Magistrate. 

"The law itself provides for lawyers of privacy for the victims. You want this to be maintained with the police station, which in our considered opinion is a gateway of disclosure of identity. The concern that you are expressing - that a person masquerades and makes false complaints in a serial manner can be restricted if there is a database. With regard to identity, in respect of sexual offenses, there is no difficulty. The law today first requires, immediately on commencement of investigation, a medical examination including DNA Profiling of the victims. if that is so, no better identification data with investigating agency can be maintained. On physical identity, the law requires recording of the statement before a Magistrate. Why should we go any further into requirement of maintenance of identity profile (of victims) at police stations?" Justice Bagchi said. 

When the petitioner's counsel urged that identification was not an issue, but rather the making of repetitive complaints, the judge expressed that everyone has a right to file complaints - be it hundred complaints. Any false complaint however shall be subject to legal consequences. 

So far as the petitioner's contention regarding payment of compensation to victims, the judge commented that the same is a concern of the state, not the petitioner. Eventually, the plea was disposed of. 

Notably, before the High Court, the petitioner pled that identity cards of complainants must be taken by the police authorities. It was claimed that an order to that effect had been passed by the Punjab and Haryana High Court. The petitioner also referred to a news report highlighting that the conviction rate of rape cases in Delhi was only 4.3%. 

Tags: