Click the Play button to listen to article

The Supreme Court on Friday(November 20) stayed the Madras High Court judgment permitting the lighting of the ceremonial Karthigai Deepam lamp at the Deepathoon (stone pillar) near a Dargah atop Thiruparankundram hill in Madurai.

However, as a one-time measure, the Court permitted the lighting of the lamp at the Deepathoon on November 24, the Karthigai Deepam day this year. The Court clarified that this arrangement should not be construed as a final endorsement of the claimed custom of lighting the lamp at the disputed location.

The permission granted by the Court cannot be relied on by any party as an evidence of any established custom, the Court clarified. It cannot also be used to claim similar performances in the subsequent years. 

A bench comprising Justice Aravind Kumar and Justice Vipul M Pancholi directed that only authorised representatives of the Devasthanam (temple administration) and government officials would be permitted to access the location for the ritual. The general public would not be allowed to go to the Deepathoon.

The Court also directed the authorities to ensure adequate security arrangements and permitted the deployment of the Central Industrial Security Force (CISF), if necessary.

Arguments so far

Senior Advocate Jaideep Gupta(State of Tamil Nadu), Senior Advocate Gopal Sankaranarayanan(Tamil Nadu District Collector), Senior Advocate Shekhar Naphade( HR&CE Commissioner), and TN Additional Advocate General Prashanto Chandra Sen made their arguments, urging a stay of the High Court's judgment.

To summarise their arguments, the counsels have categorically stated that there is no custom of lighting the lamp at the Deepathoon. They have reiterated that, as per the Agamas, the lamp is traditionally lit at the place near Uchi Pillaiyar temple.

Senior Advocate Huzefa Ahmadi for the Sikandar Badhusah Dharga and Senior Advocate Amit Tiwari(Hazarath Sulthan Sikkandar Badhusha Avuliya Dargah) made arguments, contending that they are the most affected in this case.

Ahmadi contended that the single judge made a site visit without notice to the Dharga. He submitted that if a new custom is sought to be established, it must be through a suit and not a writ proceeding.

Tiwari stated that the 1923 decree makes it clear that the Dargah has the whole ownership of the entire hillock. He contended the observation of the single judge that the Dargah is only entitled to the Nellithophe area, flight steps cut out of the rock towards the mosque and the actual site where the mosque stands, were wrong.  

Arguments were also made by Senior Advocate Narender Hooda on behalf of a priest who supports the State's position. He told the Court that the hill is very secular because it has Jain caves, Kashiviswanathan temple, dargah etc and attempts previously made to light the lamp there have been negated. He also pointed out that in a 2024, when the Dharga wanted to hold animal sacrifice within their own premises, the permission was refused. The High Court held that if a new custom had to be established, it has to be done through a custom. However, when it came to the claim of custom regarding Deepathoon, it has been allowed in a writ petition, he contended.

Arguments on behalf of the writ petitioners seeking lamp lighting at the Deepathoon.

Senior Advocate Guru Krishnakumar (for the lead petitioner) showed photographs to the Court, which are annexed with the Madras High Court order by the division bench. He stated that the photos clearly show that there are two peaks and the Deepathoon is not on the same peak as the dargah.

He also termed the arguments made in regard to the ownership of the entire hillock as "red herring". He stated that the findings are limited to the peak where the mosque and the dargah stand and not the Deepathoon, which is on the adjacent hills. He stated that attempts to include the flagstaff in the area owned by the Dargah were "spurned" by the Courts.

Background

It may be recalled that the status quo was granted by the Supreme Court after a series of orders where passed by the Madras High Court for lighting the lamp at Deepathoon. A single judge in December last year, allowed lighting of the lamp at that stop, which was upheld by the division bench of the High Court in January.

The High Court's order was passed in writ petitions filed by individuals who sought the right to light a lamp at the 'Deepa Thoon' (stone lamp pillar) atop the Thirupparankundram hills.

The spot is located about 50 meters away from a Dargah on the hill. The State HR&CE Department, which manages the Lord Subramaniya temple at the bottom of the hill, opposed the plea, contending that there was no custom of lighting the lamp at the Deepa Thoon, as it was customarily lit at another spot.

Justice GR Swaminathan of the High Court allowed the writ petition, observing that the rights of the Dargah were not affected by the act, and stopping the lamp-lighting would violate the rights of the devotees.

The refusal of the State administration to allow the lamp-lighting led to contempt proceedings, where Justice Swaminathan passed orders to execute the act with the protection of CISF forces. The division bench upheld the orders passed by Justice Swaminathan in contempt proceedings. Challenging the dismissal of the contempt proceedings, the State had filed an SLP in December last year, but the same never got listed in the Supreme Court.

In January, a division bench upheld the original orders passed by Justice Swaminathan in the writ petitions, holding that the lighting of the lamp will not cause any law and order problem. The division bench held that the temple management has the duty to protect the traditions. The division bench also rejected the argument of the State that the 'deepa thoon' was a survey stone erected by the British rulers.


Tags: