Click the Play button to listen to article

The Delhi High Court has observed that a daughter-in-law cannot be expected to vacate her senior citizen in-laws' house and relocate to an alternate accommodation without certainty regarding its standard, terms and continuity of residence.

Justice Swarana Kanta Sharma made the observation while upholding an order directing a woman and her son to vacate her in-law's property, but modifying the eviction conditions to ensure that their right to residence was adequately protected.

"The petitioner, who is stated to be dependent upon the interim maintenance of ₹30,000/- per month awarded in her favour, and who alleges substantial arrears thereof, cannot be expected to relocate to an accommodation of an unspecified standard, on uncertain terms, and without any assurance of continuity," the Court observed.

The Court was hearing a petition filed by a woman challenging an order passed under the Maintenance and Welfare of Parents and Senior Citizens Act, 2007, directing her and her son to vacate the property occupied by them.

The woman's father-in-law and mother-in-law, aged around 70 and 64 years respectively, had sought her eviction alleging harassment, ill-treatment and destruction of property.

The woman, who had been residing in the property since her marriage in 2008, claimed that it was her matrimonial home and shared household under the Protection of Women from Domestic Violence Act, 2005.

The District Magistrate had initially declined the eviction request. However, the Divisional Commissioner reversed the decision, finding that continued cohabitation had become unworkable due to persistent conflict between the parties.

The appellate authority directed the in-laws to provide reasonable alternate accommodation within 15 days, following which the woman and her son were required to vacate within seven days.

Examining the dispute, the High Court observed that the right of a daughter-in-law to reside in a shared household was not absolute and had to be balanced against the right of senior citizens to live peacefully and with dignity.

However, the Court held that the directions concerning alternate accommodation were inadequate to safeguard the residential rights of the woman and her son.

"Though the impugned order is correct in principle, the directions issued therein lack the specificity required to ensure that the right of the petitioner and her son to secure a residence is not rendered illusory," it said.

The Court further held that a period of approximately three weeks to relocate a woman who had lived in the property since 2008, along with her son studying in Class XII, was unjustified.

Taking note of the parents-in-law's willingness to contribute up to ₹35,000 per month towards alternate accommodation, the High Court modified the eviction order.

It directed the woman to identify, within four weeks, a suitable accommodation. The in-law were directed to bear rent up to ₹35,000 per month. They were also required to deposit six months' rent in advance.

The Court further directed that the obligation to provide alternate accommodation would continue until the woman's right to residence was finally adjudicated in the domestic violence or matrimonial proceedings.

For Petitioner: Mr. Sandeep Sharma, Senior Advocate with Mr. Sanjay Rathi, Mr. Sarthak Mannan, Mr. Viraj, Mr. Hitanshu Chhillar, Ms. Bhavika Rathi and Ms. Jaanvi Rathi, Advocates

For Respondents: Mr. Mohit Mathur, Senior Advocate with Mr. Atul Guleria, Mr. Aryan Rakesh, Mr. Pratishtha Singh and Mr. Vivek Maurya, Advocates. Mr. Jagdish Chandra, Ms. Maanya Saxena and Ms. Aishwarya Sinha, Advocates.

Tags: