High Court Holds It Has Jurisdiction To Hear Plea Against CARA For NOC Even Though Adoption Took Place Outside Delhi
The Delhi High Court has held that it has territorial jurisdiction to entertain a plea seeking a No Objection Certificate (NOC) from the Central Adoption Resource Authority (CARA) for relocating an adopted minor child abroad, even though the adoption proceedings took place outside Delhi.
Justice Swarana Kanta Sharma rejected the Centre's preliminary objection to the maintainability of a petition filed by an adoptive mother seeking an NOC from CARA for relocating her adopted daughter to Australia and issuance of a passport to the child.
The Court observed that although the adoption deed was executed in Amritsar, Punjab, the principal relief was sought against CARA, which is situated in the national capital.
It noted that the decision of CARA regarding the NOC was also taken in Delhi, thereby constituting a material and integral part of the cause of action.
"The principal relief sought in the petition is a writ of mandamus to CARA, an authority located within the territorial limits of this Court, and the decision of CARA, which has been challenged by the petitioner, has been taken at New Delhi; therefore, a material and integral part of the cause of action has arisen within the territorial jurisdiction of this Court," the Court observed.
The case concerns a minor girl who was adopted in 2021 under the Hindu Adoptions and Maintenance Act, 1956, by a couple who are Australian citizens of Indian origin and hold Overseas Citizen of India (OCI) cards.
The adoption deed was registered in Amritsar and subsequently recognised by a civil court in January 2024. However, the adoptive parents claimed that the child's passport application could not be processed in the absence of an NOC from CARA.
CARA had asked the parents to follow the prescribed procedure requiring sponsorship by the competent authority of the receiving country. The parents claimed that the Australian authorities declined to initiate the process and advised them to pursue an immigration route, which also required CARA's NOC.
The parents thereafter approached the High Court seeking directions for issuance of the NOC and the child's passport.
The Ministry of External Affairs and Regional Passport Office, Amritsar, objected to the petition's maintainability, arguing that all material events, including the adoption and passport application, had occurred in Punjab.
Rejecting the objection, Justice Sharma held that the adoption deed, updation of birth records and civil court decree were merely background facts and were not under challenge in the petition.
It further observed that the relief sought against the passport authorities was consequential and depended upon CARA's decision regarding the NOC.
The Court also noted that CARA, the principal contesting respondent, had not raised any objection regarding territorial jurisdiction and had instead contested the petition on merits.
On the question of whether the Court should decline to exercise jurisdiction under the doctrine of forum conveniens, Justice Sharma observed that the petition had been pending since April and the pleadings were complete.
The Court emphasised that the dispute involved the relocation of a minor child, which according to the petitioners had remained unresolved for nearly five years.
"Relegating the petitioners to another forum at this stage would neither advance the cause of justice nor subserve the best interests of the child, which must remain a paramount consideration in matters of this nature," the Court said.
Accordingly, the Court rejected the preliminary objection regarding territorial jurisdiction and directed the matter be placed before the roster bench for adjudication on December 02.
For Petitioners: Ms. Sheenam Chhabra, Ms. Anjani Chhabra and Ms. Nibha Gupta, Advocates
For Respondents: Mr. Puneet Yadav, SPC with Mr. Kamaldeep, GP and with SI Satish Dahiya, Delhi Police. Mr. Piyush Beriwal, Ms. Ruchita Srivastava and Mr. Sparsh Jain, Advocates for R-1 to R-5. Mr. V.N. Raghupathy, Ms. Mythili S., Ms. P. Chandni, Mr. Sumit Bhargava and Ms. Chandni Godiyal, Advocates for R-6/CARA.