Click the Play button to listen to article
story

The Delhi High Court has observed that the Standard Operating Procedure (SOP) governing the cyber-fraud reporting mechanism cannot be invoked to undo voluntary contractual transactions between known parties, particularly where the transactions have been acknowledged by the parties and form part of an existing dispute.Justice Amit Mahajan made the observation while directing lifting of the...

Your free access to Live Law has expired
Please Subscribe for unlimited access to Live Law Archives, Weekly/Monthly Digest, Exclusive Notifications, Comments, Ad Free Version, Petition Copies, Judgement/Order Copies.

The Delhi High Court has observed that the Standard Operating Procedure (SOP) governing the cyber-fraud reporting mechanism cannot be invoked to undo voluntary contractual transactions between known parties, particularly where the transactions have been acknowledged by the parties and form part of an existing dispute.

Justice Amit Mahajan made the observation while directing lifting of the freeze and lien imposed on two bank accounts of a father-son duo pursuant to a cybercrime complaint alleging that Rs. 30 lakh had been fraudulently transferred.

The Court observed that the cyber-fraud reporting mechanism and the administrative SOPs governing it are intended to facilitate prompt intervention in cases where financial transactions result from cyber fraud and immediate coordination with banks and financial institutions is required to prevent further dissipation of funds.

“The said mechanism is not intended to be invoked as a means of undoing voluntary contractual transfers between known parties, particularly where such transactions have been acknowledged inter partes and form part of some dispute,” the Court observed.

The plea was filed by one Sarabjit Singh Chadha and his son Gursimran Singh Chadha seeking quashing of a cybercrime complaint registered on the National Cyber Crime Reporting Portal (NCCRP) and de-freezing of their bank accounts maintained with Kotak Mahindra Bank's Karol Bagh branch.

The dispute arose from a property transaction dating back to July 2013, when Sarabjit Singh Chadha entered into an agreement to purchase a property from M/s S.K.G. Doors Pvt. Ltd. for Rs. 60 lakh. He paid Rs. 30 lakh as earnest money.

After the company allegedly failed to execute the sale deed, Chadha instituted a suit for specific performance in 2016. The parties subsequently decided to settle the dispute, with the company agreeing to refund the earnest money of Rs. 30 lakh.

Pursuant to a settlement deed executed on March 16, the amount was transferred from the bank account of one Neetu Goyal, director of the company, to Chadha's account on March 17, in four tranches. The amount was subsequently transferred by Chadha to his son's account as part of a family arrangement.

However, on March 18, Neetu Goyal's daughter, Shreya Goyal, lodged a complaint on the NCCRP alleging internet banking-related fraud and claiming that her mother had mistakenly transferred Rs. 30 lakh.

During the subsequent enquiry, the complainant submitted a supplementary complaint giving a different version of the transaction. It alleged that the complainant and her family had visited Chadha's business premises in Defence Colony for purchasing raw gold as an investment and that he had induced them to transfer Rs. 30 lakh on the promise of supplying gold, which was allegedly never supplied.

The Court noted that the investigating agency itself had recorded that the two versions were materially different and mutually contradictory.

Significantly, the status report filed by the Assistant Commissioner of Police, Central Cyber Cell, stated that the dispute did not prima facie disclose the ingredients of cyber fraud and that the disputed amount had been voluntarily transferred through banking channels by the account holder or her family members.

The investigating agency also expressed no objection to de-freezing the petitioners' bank accounts, although it sought that the disputed amount of Rs. 30 lakh continue to remain on hold until completion of the enquiry.

The Court, however, observed that when specifically asked under which statutory provision the amount had been directed to be secured, the respondent authorities could not provide a satisfactory response.

It further rejected the authorities' reliance on the Supreme Court's directions in Re: Victims of Digital Arrest Related to Forged Documents and the Ministry of Home Affairs' SOP dated January 02.

The Court specifically referred to Section III, Clause 10.2 of the SOP, which provides that directions for seizure of bank accounts or suspension of digital banking services shall be issued under Section 106 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita (BNSS), 2023, or other applicable laws.

It noted that the respondents did not dispute that no order under Section 106 of BNSS was passed to restrict the petitioners from operating their bank accounts.

In these circumstances, the Court held that permitting the continued freezing of the accounts would result in a private dispute between known parties being given the complexion of a cyber-fraud case.

Accordingly, it directed that the freeze and lien imposed on the petitioners' bank accounts be lifted.

“Needless to state, this Court is conscious of the need for prompt intervention in genuine cyber-fraud cases and the present order should not be construed as diluting the efficacy of the cyber-fraud reporting mechanism or the guidelines/SOPs governing such cases,” the Court said.

It clarified: “The present directions are passed only considering that the investigating agency itself does not regard the material as prima facie constituting cyber fraud and as per their own enquiry the transactions have been found to be related to a private civil dispute.”

It also clarified that the order would not prevent the investigating agency or any competent authority from taking action permissible in law by following the appropriate statutory procedure.

Further, the Court did not quash the NCCRP complaint, observing that the rival versions raised factual issues which could not be conclusively determined in the writ proceedings.

The Court granted parties liberty to pursue their remedies concerning the underlying civil or commercial dispute.

Tags: