Delhi High Court Rejects Plea Over Alleged Forced Religious Conversion Of Adivasi Families In Chhattisgarh, Cites Lack Of Jurisdiction
The Delhi High Court has refused to entertain a plea over the alleged forced religious conversion and displacement of Adivasi families in Chhattisgarh, holding that the Chhattisgarh High Court is the appropriate forum to examine their grievances.
Justice Swarana Kanta Sharma held that the mere fact that the National Human Rights Commission (NHRC) is headquartered in Delhi and passed the order under challenge from the national capital would not, by itself, confer territorial jurisdiction on the Delhi High Court.
The Court observed that the petitioner, the victims, the place of incident, the authorities concerned and the entire relevant record were situated in Sukma district of Chhattisgarh.
The petition was filed by Baman Ram Kawasi, who alleged that several Adivasi families practising Christianity in Village Chitlanar, Sukma, were threatened with violence and forced to leave their homes after refusing to convert to Hinduism.
According to the plea, on March 05, a mob, including local Panchayat members, allegedly entered the homes of Christian Adivasi families and demanded that they either convert to Hinduism or leave the village. Upon their refusal, two persons were allegedly assaulted with lathis and subsequently hospitalised at District Hospital, Sukma.
The petitioner further alleged that the families were threatened with death and forced to leave the village. The affected families, including women, children and elderly persons, allegedly remained displaced and were living in makeshift shelters in Sukma town.
It was also alleged that despite complaints to the police and district administration, no effective action was taken. On March 17, the mob allegedly again threatened the families with death if they returned to the village without renouncing Christianity and accepting Hinduism.
The petitioner thereafter approached the National Human Rights Commission (NHRC) with a detailed complaint under Sections 12, 13, 17 and 18 of the Protection of Human Rights Act, 1993.
On June 09, the NHRC disposed of the complaint by transmitting it to the District Magistrate and Superintendent of Police, Sukma, with directions to take appropriate action within eight weeks, associate the complainant or victims in the process and inform them of the action taken.
Aggrieved by the NHRC's decision to dispose of the complaint, the petitioner approached the Delhi High Court seeking a direction to treat the NHRC's order as an interim direction rather than a final disposal of his complaint. He also sought fresh consideration of the complaint by the Commission, including an opportunity of hearing before any order of disposal.
The Union Government opposed the plea, arguing that the entire cause of action had arisen in Sukma, as the alleged incidents, displacement and inaction were attributable to the local police and district administration. It also contended that the mere fact that the NHRC was headquartered in Delhi could not confer territorial jurisdiction on the High Court.
The petitioner, on the other hand, argued that the challenge was directed against a specific decision taken by the NHRC at New Delhi and, therefore, a material part of the cause of action had arisen within the territorial jurisdiction of the Delhi High Court.
Rejecting the contention, the Court observed that the NHRC had merely acted as a channel by forwarding the complaint to the very authorities at Sukma against whom the grievance was directed.
“The impugned order does not adjudicate upon any right or claim of the petitioner,” the Court observed.
It added that it merely transmitted the complaint to the District Magistrate and Superintendent of Police, Sukma, directing them to take appropriate action within eight weeks.
The Court further observed that examining the reliefs sought by the petitioner would inevitably require consideration of the incidents in Sukma, the alleged inaction of the local police and administration and the action taken by them pursuant to the NHRC's directions.
It also noted that neither the State of Chhattisgarh nor the District Magistrate or Superintendent of Police, Sukma, against whom the allegations of inaction were directed, had been impleaded as parties to the proceedings.
The Court cautioned that accepting the petitioner's argument would mean that every order passed by the NHRC concerning an incident anywhere in the country could be challenged before the Delhi High Court merely because the Commission has its office in the national capital.
Holding that the Chhattisgarh High Court had the most direct and substantial connection with the dispute, Justice Sharma observed that it would be the most appropriate forum to examine the petitioner's grievances.
The Court accordingly dismissed the plea for want of territorial jurisdiction and on the principle of forum conveniens, while granting the petitioner liberty to avail remedies available under law before the appropriate forum, including the Chhattisgarh High Court.
It clarified that it had not expressed any opinion on the merits of the allegations or the other objections raised by the authorities.