Click the Play button to listen to article

The Delhi High Court has observed that a senior citizen cannot be compelled to share his own house with his children against his wishes, particularly when the relationship has deteriorated to such an extent that he has been constrained to litigate against them and seek police assistance.

“At the age of 85 years, the petitioner is entitled to live in his own house peacefully and with dignity,” Justice Amit Mahajan observed.

The Court made the observations while allowing a plea filed by an 85-year-old man seeking eviction of his eldest son and daughter-in-law from his self-acquired property in Delhi.

The Court set aside orders passed by the District Magistrate and the Divisional Commissioner rejecting his eviction plea under the Maintenance and Welfare of Parents and Senior Citizens Act, 2007, and directed the son and daughter-in-law to vacate the property within four weeks.

The petitioner had approached the Court alleging that his son and daughter-in-law had been harassing him and disturbing his peace. He submitted that despite being the absolute owner of the property, he was unable to live peacefully in his own house.

The petitioner, who acquired the property from the Delhi Development Authority in 1980 and subsequently converted it into freehold in 2000, stated that his eldest son and daughter-in-law had been residing there since their marriage in 2003.

According to the petitioner, despite being asked to make alternate accommodation arrangements, they refused to vacate the premises. He further alleged that their behaviour towards him deteriorated over the years and that they stopped supporting him financially. He also alleged that the harassment intensified after his wife's death in November 2020.

The petitioner further alleged that his son and daughter-in-law had threatened him and assaulted his youngest son in September 2022, following which he lodged a police complaint.

He subsequently approached the authorities under the Senior Citizens Act, seeking eviction of the two respondents from his property and maintenance.

However, the District Magistrate rejected his plea, observing that the allegations of harassment had not been established and that the dispute appeared to be a family and property dispute between the petitioner's sons.

The Divisional Commissioner subsequently upheld the decision, observing that the provisions of the Act could not be invoked to settle private family or property disputes in the absence of clear and credible evidence of neglect or harassment.

Before the High Court, the petitioner argued that being the absolute owner of the property, he was entitled to reside there peacefully and seek eviction of his son and daughter-in-law if their presence disturbed his peace.

The respondents, on the other hand, contended that the dispute was essentially a business dispute between the petitioner's sons and that they had been taking care of him. They also pointed out that they had offered to pay him maintenance of Rs 15,000.

The High Court observed that the Supreme Court in Ravi Kant Gupta v. State of Uttar Pradesh had recognised the power of Maintenance Tribunals to order eviction of children from a senior citizen's property where such a measure was necessary and expedient for the senior citizen's maintenance and protection.

The Court also relied on its earlier decision in Pritam Singh v. Government of NCT of Delhi, wherein it was held that a senior citizen seeking protection of his property need not necessarily establish that he requires maintenance or has been ill-treated by his children.

“Thus, in view of the dictum in Pritam Singh (supra), a senior citizen seeking eviction of his children from his property is not necessarily required to show that he has been ill-treated by them. It is sufficient if he shows that his property needs protection, so that he can live therein peacefully and with dignity,” the Court observed.

Applying the said principles, the Court held that the authorities had proceeded on an erroneous premise by insisting that the petitioner establish harassment through clear and cogent evidence before eviction could be ordered.

It observed that neither the Senior Citizens Act nor the Delhi Maintenance and Welfare of Parents and Senior Citizens Rules, 2009, prescribed such a requirement.

The Court further noted that the authorities had failed to consider the multiple police complaints lodged by the petitioner since 2022 and the fact that the High Court had earlier directed the concerned police station to provide him assistance to obviate any threat from his son and daughter-in-law.

It added that the mere existence of a business dispute between the petitioner's sons could not, by itself, be a ground to conclude that the senior citizen's grievance was not genuine or deny him protection under the Act.

The Court also found fault with the enquiry reports submitted by the Sub-Divisional Magistrate.

It observed that the first report had merely recorded that the genuineness of the harassment complaint could not be ascertained, and therefore could not have been treated as proof that the allegations stood disproved.

The second report was also found to be deficient as it recorded the submissions of both parties and noted that a house visit had been conducted, but did not discuss the material placed on record or explain how the allegations of harassment had been examined.

“A conclusion bereft of reasons cannot be termed a finding,” the Court observed.

It further remarked that instances of harassment of senior citizens by their children often take place within the four walls of a house and may be difficult to establish through independent evidence.

Justice Mahajan added that proceedings under the Senior Citizens Act are summary in nature and authorities cannot insist upon the same standard of proof as required in civil or criminal trials.

Accordingly, the Court set aside the orders passed by the Divisional Commissioner and the District Magistrate and directed the petitioner's son and daughter-in-law to vacate the property within four weeks.

The concerned Station House Officer has also been directed to render all necessary assistance to the petitioner to ensure compliance with the order, if required.

Tags: