Centre's Order Cancelling Author Amrit Wilson's OCI Card Lacks Details Of 'Anti-India Activities': Delhi High Court
The Delhi High Court has observed that the Centre's order cancelling the Overseas Citizen of India (OCI) card of UK-based author and journalist Amrit Wilson does not specify the alleged anti-India activities attributed to her, thereby depriving her of an opportunity to respond to the allegations.
Justice Amit Mahajan held that the principles of natural justice were not followed in the cancellation proceedings, as neither the show cause notice nor the cancellation order disclosed specific details of the alleged activities.
The Court was hearing a plea filed by Wilson challenging the March 17, 2023 order cancelling her OCI card under Section 7D(e) of the Citizenship Act, 1955.
Wilson was born in India and lived here until 1961, when she moved to the United Kingdom for higher studies. She subsequently settled in the UK and worked as a writer, journalist and social activist.
She surrendered her Indian passport and acquired a British passport in 2009. She was issued a Person of Indian Origin (PIO) card in 2014 and was subsequently granted an OCI card on December 20, 2017.
In November 2022, the authorities issued her a show cause notice alleging that she was engaged in “detrimental propaganda against the Indian government” and had been involved in multiple anti-India activities allegedly inimical to India's sovereignty and integrity, security and public interest.
The notice directed her to explain within 15 days why her OCI card should not be cancelled under Section 7D(e) of the Citizenship Act.
In her reply, Wilson denied involvement in any anti-India activities and pointed out that the authorities had not disclosed any specific allegations against her. She also sought disclosure of the material forming the basis of the notice to enable her to effectively present her case.
However, the authorities did not issue any further communication for the next three months and proceeded to cancel her OCI registration on March 17, 2023.
Before the High Court, her counsel argued that the authorities had failed to disclose the specific incidents forming the basis of the cancellation. It was also submitted that even in their counter-affidavit before the Court, the respondents had not disclosed the reasons for cancellation, claiming that the material could only be placed before the Court in a sealed cover.
The Court noted that a perusal of the show cause notice and the cancellation order revealed that neither contained specific details of the alleged anti-India activities attributed to Wilson.
“A perusal of the SCN and the impugned order indicates that the same is bereft of any specific details of Anti-India activities in which the petitioner was involved, thus, providing no opportunity to the petitioner to provide an explanation in respect of the same,” the Court said.
Observing that this deprived her of an opportunity to explain her conduct, the Court said:
“It is trite law that a SCN must specifically indicate the case that a noticee has to meet.”
The Court further observed that no specific reasons had been provided in the counter-affidavit filed before it to enable the petitioner to submit an appropriate response.
It added that the petitioner's rights under Section 7B of the Citizenship Act could not be taken away without providing her an appropriate opportunity to respond to the allegations.
Accordingly, the Court directed the authorities to issue a fresh show cause notice within one week, spelling out the specific reasons for cancellation of her OCI card.
The Court clarified that if the reasons could not be disclosed in full, the petitioner must be provided with the gist of the material, after redacting sensitive information, or be permitted to inspect the material that led to the cancellation.
Wilson was directed to file her reply within one week of receiving the fresh notice, following which the authorities must pass a fresh order within two weeks.
In the meantime, the cancellation order will remain operative for four weeks or until a fresh order is passed, whichever is earlier.