Click the Play button to listen to article

The Delhi High Court has upheld the life sentence awarded to a police officer convicted of murdering two persons in 2011, observing that his abuse of the position of trust reposed in him as a protector of citizens constituted a significant aggravating circumstance.

The division bench of Justice Navin Chawla and Justice Ravinder Dudeja dismissed the appeal filed by convict Ajay Kumar Tomar challenging his conviction and sentence. It also rejected appeals filed by the Delhi Police and the son of one of the deceased seeking enhancement of his sentence to death penalty.

The Court observed that the convict, being a police officer entrusted with protecting citizens and upholding the rule of law, had himself become the perpetrator of two murders. However, it clarified that the policeman's position could not independently justify capital punishment.

"...the appellant's status as a police officer and the breach of trust of the public, which believes the police officials to be their protectors, while undoubtedly an aggravating circumstance, cannot by itself furnish the basis for capital punishment," the Court said.

The case arose from an incident on September 24, 2011, when Tomar, wearing a police uniform, stopped a car driven by Amarjeet Singh Chadha near Railway Hospital in Delhi.

According to the prosecution, Tomar entered the vehicle, snatched gold chains worn by Chadha and fired three shots at him, resulting in his death.

While fleeing the spot, Tomar was pursued by Head Constable Surender Kumar, who took assistance from a civilian motorcyclist, Harender Singh alias Sunny. During the chase, Tomar fired at his pursuers, hitting Sunny in the neck. Sunny subsequently succumbed to his injuries.

In December 2021, the trial court convicted Tomar for both murders, robbery involving a deadly weapon and offences under the Arms Act. In May 2022, it sentenced him to life imprisonment for each murder, besides imposing separate sentences for the other offences.

Before the High Court, Tomar challenged the reliability of eyewitness accounts, alleged inconsistencies in the recovery of weapons and questioned the forensic evidence.

The Court however found that the eyewitness testimonies were supported by medical records, ballistic examination, fingerprint evidence and recovery of the robbed jewellery.

It held that minor discrepancies and investigative deficiencies did not undermine the prosecution's case, which established the commission of both murders beyond reasonable doubt.

On the question of enhancement of sentence, the State and the victim's son argued that the gravity of the offences, the use of firearms and the convict's position as a police officer warranted capital punishment.

The Court acknowledged the gravity of the crimes but observed, “the material on record does not reveal such exceptional brutality, extraordinary depravity or circumstances of such nature as would justify the conclusion that the appellant's case stands beyond the possibility of reform or rehabilitation.”

For Appellant: Mr. Sudarshan Rajan, Mr. Hitain Bajaj & Mr.Sunny Sharma, Advs.

For Respondents: Mr. Aman Usman, APP with Mr. Manvendra Yadav, Adv. for State along with Insp. Manoj Kumar, PS Lahori Gate. Mr. Pawan Reley, Mr. Akshay Lodhi, Ms. Simran Singh, Mr. Gaurav Kumar, Mr. Tanish Rawat & Mr. Prakhar Agrawal, Advs. for R-2.

Tags: