Antedating Promotion Of Retired Employee Can't Be Allowed To Disturb Seniority Of Others: Gauhati High Court
The Gauhati High Court has set aside an order of the Central Administrative Tribunal directing BSNL to hold a review DPC (Departmental Promotion Committee) for antedated promotion of a retired engineer, observing that the exercise would be meaningless and would unnecessarily disturb the seniority of retired employees.A Division Bench of Chief Justice Ashutosh Kumar and Justice Kaushik...
The Gauhati High Court has set aside an order of the Central Administrative Tribunal directing BSNL to hold a review DPC (Departmental Promotion Committee) for antedated promotion of a retired engineer, observing that the exercise would be meaningless and would unnecessarily disturb the seniority of retired employees.
A Division Bench of Chief Justice Ashutosh Kumar and Justice Kaushik Goswami observed, "we find that the respondent was promoted to the post of Chief Engineer and has now retired. The entire exercise of holding a DPC for giving antedated promotion to the respondent to the post of Superintendent Engineer (Civil) would be meaningless and would unnecessarily disturb the pecking order of seniority of the retired employees."
The observation came in a writ petition filed by BSNL challenging the order passed by the Central Administrative Tribunal, Guwahati Bench, directing it to hold a review DPC for considering the case of Udit Gupta for early promotion/antedated promotion in view of the Supreme Court's judgment in Shiv Kumar Sharma and Another v. Union of India and Others.
Gupta started his service in BSNL in 1992 as an Assistant Executive Engineer (Civil) and was given an ad-hoc promotion to the post of Superintending Engineer (Civil) in 2005. He was never given regular promotion on account of remarks of "below the benchmark" in his APARs/Annual Confidential Reports.
The Tribunal noted that he was the topper of his batch of engineers and was denied time-bound promotion for not meeting the benchmark gradings in his APARs, which it also linked to his being a whistle-blower in the department.
BSNL submitted that the challenge came after several years, when Gupta's juniors had already been promoted and most of them had retired. It argued that antedating his promotion would disturb the seniority of 40 other employees who had been promoted before him and were not impleaded as parties. It further submitted that the judgment in Shiv Kumar Sharma was delivered in separate special circumstances and could not automatically be applied to Gupta, as BSNL had its own promotion rules.
The High Court noted that the Tribunal had applied the principle in Shiv Kumar Sharma, under which the grading of employees who shouldered higher responsibilities for a higher Class I post could be treated as one level higher than the grading awarded to them for that period.
"Thus, applying the afore-noted principle and taking the grading of the respondent to one higher level, it was found that perhaps the respondent would have qualified for being promoted to the higher post much earlier, i.e. when his juniors were considered."
The Court, however, found that Gupta had already been promoted to the post of Chief Engineer and had retired. It held that holding a DPC for giving him antedated promotion to the post of Superintending Engineer (Civil) would be meaningless and would unnecessarily disturb the seniority of retired employees.
"Thus, we do not find the directions issued by the Tribunal to be tenable."
"We are, thus, constrained to set aside the impugned order passed by the Tribunal."
Accordingly, the High Court allowed BSNL's writ petition.