Click the Play button to listen to article

The Supreme Court on Friday issued notice on a special leave petition against the Allahabad High Court's August ruling that struck down key provisions of the Uttar Pradesh Regulation of Urban Premises Tenancy Act, 2021. It also ordered that pending proceedings under the Act will not be thrown out because of that ruling for now.

A bench of Justice Prashant Kumar Mishra and Justice Shree Chandrashekhar directed that during pendency of the SLP, proceedings pending under the relevant provisions of the 2021 Act will not be dismissed on account of the impugned order.

“Issue notice to the respondent(s), however, proceedings pending under the relevant provision of UP Regulation of Urban Premises Tenancy Act, 2021 (U.P. Act No 16 of 2021), shall not be dismissed as not maintainable or abated, on account of the impugned order, during pendency of this Special Leave Petition”, the Court ordered.

On August 21, a Division Bench of Justice Saumitra Dayal Singh and Justice Swarupama Chaturvedi decided a batch of about 16 writ petitions and declared Sections 8, 9, 10, 38 and 42 of the Act ultra vires, effective from the date of judgment.

Sections 8 to 10 deal with rent, its revision and its determination by the Rent Authority. Section 38 bars civil courts from hearing matters covered by the Act, and Section 42 gives the Act overriding effect.

The court held that the rent provisions and the Act's eviction grounds conflict with the Transfer of Property Act, 1882, and that Sections 38 and 42 conflict with the Provincial Small Causes Courts Act, 1887. Both Central laws, together with a 1972 Uttar Pradesh amendment that had received Presidential assent, fall under the Concurrent List. The HC held that a State law overriding them needed Presidential assent under Article 254(2) of the Constitution, which the 2021 Act did not have. It also found that the Act's "penal rent" for tenants who fail to vacate, and its landlord-heir eviction right, cannot be reconciled with the 1882 Act.

The court held that the repealed Uttar Pradesh Urban Buildings (Regulation of Letting, Rent and Eviction) Act, 1972 would "spring back to life" to the extent required. It protected proceedings already concluded without challenge, and rents already revised under the Act, from the declaration.

Applying the ruling to the case before it, the High Court quashed an April 25, 2025 order of the Additional District Judge, Farrukhabad directing shop tenants Rajendra Kumar Agarwal and Narendra Kumar Agarwal to vacate within 30 days. That order had been passed in favour of landlords Tarun, Vishal and Nitin Gupta, on appeal after the Rent Authority dismissed their eviction application under Section 21(2) of the 2021 Act in December 2024.

Their eviction application, filed in September 2022, cited personal need and the building's dilapidated condition. They have now approached the Supreme Court against the High Court order.

The appellants argue that the High Court never identified the "direct, irreconcilable" conflict that the doctrine of repugnancy requires, and that it ignored the presumption of validity of State laws. They contend that the 2021 Act supplements the 1882 Act by applying to written tenancies and providing a speedy forum, rather than contradicting it. They also argue that Section 42 overrides the Uttar Pradesh amendment to the Small Causes Courts Act.

They further contend that a repealed Act is extinguished and cannot be revived by a court, and the power of "prospective overruling" belongs to the Supreme Court alone, not to High Courts. They describe the October 5 order as a review in the guise of a clarification. And they say the writ petition should have been dismissed because Section 21, under which their eviction case was brought, was never declared invalid.

Appearance –

For the Petitioner- Kavin Gulati Senior Advocate, Ashish Chaudhary (AoR), Siddhant Singh (Advocate).

For Respondents- Dama Seshadri Naidu, Senior Advocate, Rohit Amit Sthalekar (AoR), Shreya Gupta (Advocate).

Tags: