Editors Pick

Bombay HC orders demolition of Adarsh Building. Here's why? Read Judgment

Ashok KM
2 May 2016 1:41 PM GMT
Bombay HC orders demolition of Adarsh Building. Here
Your free access to Live Law has expired
To read the article, get a premium account.
    Your Subscription Supports Independent Journalism
Subscription starts from
(For 6 Months)
Premium account gives you:
  • Unlimited access to Live Law Archives, Weekly/Monthly Digest, Exclusive Notifications, Comments.
  • Reading experience of Ad Free Version, Petition Copies, Judgement/Order Copies.
Already a subscriber?

Prima facie, the bureaucrats and the ministers are guilty of various offences in acquiring the subject plot as also misuse and / or abuse of powers, the Court said.

The Bombay High Court, has asked the Ministry of Environment and Forests to forthwith demolish Adarsh building which was unauthorisedly constructed by the Adarsh Co-op. Housing Society Ltd in violation to Environmental norms. Division Bench comprising of Justices Ranjit More and R.G. Ketkar also called for initiating appropriate civil / criminal proceedings against the concerned bureaucrats, ministers and politicians who are connected to the corruption in relation to the construction.

In a 227 page judgment which dismissed the petition by Adarsh Co-op. Housing Society Ltd by imposing costs of six lakhs, the bench observed “It cannot be disputed that the bureaucrats and ministers are custodians of the Government property. They are entrusted with the Government property. People repose confidence in them that the Government property is in the safe hands of bureaucrats and ministers and that they will protect the Government property. Prima facie, they have dishonestly disposed of the property in violation of the settled position of law. In our opinion, prima facie, the bureaucrats and the ministers are guilty of various offences in acquiring the subject plot as also misuse and / or abuse of powers.”

The Court observed that the society had not obtained recommendations of MCZMA and environmental clearance either from MOEF or State level agencies.  “It is also brought on record that bureaucrats, ministers, army officers or their kith and kin became members of Adarsh Society. It cannot be said to be a sheer coincidence. Prima facie, the possibility of quid pro quo cannot be ruled out. This Court cannot remain a mute spectator and shut its eyes to these illegalities.”,the Bench remarked.

The Court also said that the allotment was not made in a transparent manner and it clearly smacks out favouritism and / or nepotism. “The greedy person is always looking after opportunities to secure unfair advantage by hook or crook. It is said that every greedy person is a criminal and every criminal is a greedy person.”,the Court added. However, the Court has demolition is stayed for twelve weeks so that the petitioners could approach the Apex Court if required.

Image from here.

Read the Judgment here.

Next Story