AAG Farasat also gives a short rejoinder . Sr Adv Mr Kapil Sibal submits rejoinder on the issue of homogeneity of caste

Sibal : 1. argument that SCs have to be determined on the basis of untouchablity means we have to divide the population - this would be violative of 14 ; 2. the concept of class is in the context of identification not for the purposes of granting representation in services.