Top Stories

Essar Leaks: CPIL files PIL in SC seeking a Court monitored investigation by CBI or SIT

Apoorva Mandhani
27 Feb 2015 1:32 PM GMT
Essar Leaks: CPIL files PIL in SC seeking a Court monitored investigation by CBI or SIT
Your free access to Live Law has expired
To read the article, get a premium account.
    Your Subscription Supports Independent Journalism
Subscription starts from
(For 6 Months)
Premium account gives you:
  • Unlimited access to Live Law Archives, Weekly/Monthly Digest, Exclusive Notifications, Comments.
  • Reading experience of Ad Free Version, Petition Copies, Judgement/Order Copies.
Already a subscriber?

A Public Interest Litigation has been filed by Advocate Prashant Bhushan for and on behalf of Centre for Public Interest Litigation in Supreme Court demanding a Court monitored investigation by an SIT or the CBI into “the high level of political bureaucratic corporate nexus wherein corporates use their money power to change public policies, plant questions in Parliament, get access to internal government documents/cabinet papers, grant favors to politicians and bureaucrats for receiving benefits in return, and plant stories in news media.

It states, That the internal emails and documents from one of India’s biggest business group reveal how in violation of the Constitution and the laws of the land, the major corporate like Essar manage to influence the political executive, the bureaucracy, the police and the media, in order to serve its business interests rather than public interest which they are legally obligated to uphold.

The basis of the Petition is alleged internal emails and documents from the Essar group of Companies which is one of India’s leading business conglomerate having multi-billion dollar investments in Oil, steel, energy, ports, shipping, infrastructure and services sectors in India.

CPIL in its petition claims to be in possession of internals emails and documents of the Essar Group, through a confidential source, the identity of which it does not disclose. The Petition claims that the confidential information indicates how Essar has been cultivating ministers, politicians, bureaucrats and journalists in order to serve its business interests. Essar, in turn, apparently gets favored from such influential persons who can take executive decisions, change public policies, raise questions in Parliament, leak confidential government documents and plant stories in the media, it alleges.

The Petition alleges that the internal reports and Emails from Essar reveal that the group is apparently planting questions in Parliament.

The petitioner claims that a Monthly Information System (MIS) report dated 27.08.2012 was prepared by Essar’s Senior Vice-President on various business interests of Essar including Steel, Mines, Shipping etc. The chapter on steel sector of the said report allegedly states: “Planted Parliamentary Questions regarding arbitrary pricing mechanism of NMDC which are expected to be answered on the floor of House on 27th August and 3rd September, 2012, respectively.” On another issue concerning the company, the said report reads: “Planning to plant Parliament Questions by September 2012.

This information has been corroborated by the Petitioner through an Email alleged to have been tosent to the senior management and owners of Essar on 23.08.2012 inter-alia stating: “An early action will keep the pressure on NMDC, as the questions planted in Parliament will be heard on 27th August 2012.

It further alleges that the company has institutionalized a mechanism to bestow significant favors, monetary benefits and shower gifts on persons with influence. As an evidence of this claim, the Petition relies on an inter-office note sent by Essar’s President, Corporate Affairs in June 2009 which allegedly states: “With the new UPA govt. taking over at Centre and their fresh innings starting, this is an opportune moment for us to invest on right people at right places for reaping long term benefits. I have noticed that quite a lot of them, especially the young parliamentarians, are techno-savvy and they prefer to communicate over emails and sms than traditional letters. We have to have the right strategy to penetrate this base, and with this in mind, I propose to gift about 200 top-end cell phones to some of these esteemed leaders, and also some of the top bureaucrats. These phones will have SIM cards supported by us by about Rs 5000/- per month.

Another alleged email transcript produced in the petition talks about Deepawali and New Year gifts to Government officials. Another document called the ‘Daily Calling Report’ indicates that the company officers are regularly meeting scores of politicians, bureaucrats and journalists everyday to plant questions in Parliament, push public policies, gain access to confidential information and documents from inside the ministries and to plant stories in the media.

It has been alleged in the petition that large number of MPs have been meeting corporate officials and apparently assuring “active support” for Essar’s business interests as part of their official duty would, according to the Petition, amount to an offence under Section 13 of the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988.

Essar allegedly also sponsors luxury travel of influential politicians and their family members.It claims that all arrangements are made by Essar for the visit of a Union Minister and his 8 family members, including pick up by a helicopter from the Nice airport to the cruise and all meals during their stay.

Another alleged inter office note relied upon in the petition and series of alleged emails reveal how Essar has institutionalized the practice of granting jobs to persons who have he backing of the ministers, politicians, senior bureaucrats, and other influential persons.

Several instances of planting stories in media and bestowing favours have been spelled out in the Petition. One suchalleged  email talks about scheming to plant a story in Reuters in response to its story in November 2013 which had stated that a China-bound Essar vessel carrying iron ore was arrested in Singapore.

Several alleged Emails have been attached approving official Essar transport to journalists who have written scathing articles against Essar in the past.

Essar Group has mining operations in some areas that are marked as sensitive due to active Maoist groups. It has been alleged that Essar Group has been funding the Maoist groups such that they steer clear of the group’s business interests. Chhattisgarh police has registered a case for payment of Maoists and had arrested Essar’s senior executive as well as their building contractor . The Petition further strengthens such claims from emails which confirm such payments to armed militant elements.

The Petition finally pleads, That the entire matter is crying out for a thorough court-monitored investigation by an SIT or CBI since the same is necessary to uphold democracy, the rule of law and rights of the citizens under Articles 14 and 21 of the Constitution of India.

It also demands that the Government should cancel privileges like subsidized land, newsprint, houses etc. that have been extended to media organizations and journalists who are indulging in paid news, or publishing news reports to favor corporates, or who are taking favors from corporates, after a suitable inquiry is carried out by an independent committee into the issues and instances raised in this petition.

Next Story