Top Stories

#MeToo: External Committee Headed By Former SC Judge Aftab Alam To Examine Sexual Harassment Allegations Against Vinod Dua

Apoorva Mandhani
20 Oct 2018 9:06 AM GMT
#MeToo: External Committee Headed By Former SC Judge Aftab Alam To Examine Sexual Harassment Allegations Against Vinod Dua
Your free access to Live Law has expired
To read the article, get a premium account.
    Your Subscription Supports Independent Journalism
Subscription starts from
(For 6 Months)
Premium account gives you:
  • Unlimited access to Live Law Archives, Weekly/Monthly Digest, Exclusive Notifications, Comments.
  • Reading experience of Ad Free Version, Petition Copies, Judgement/Order Copies.
Already a subscriber?

The Wire has constituted an external committee headed by former Supreme Court judge, Justice Aftab Alam to probe the sexual harassment allegations levied against its consulting editor Vinod Dua, by film maker Nishtha Jain.

The committee also comprises of former Patna High Court judge Justice Anjana Prakash, retired Delhi University professor Neera Chandhoke, retired Institute of Economic Growth professor Patricia Uberoi, and former foreign secretary Ambassador Sujatha Singh.

A one-person secretariat has also been established to assist the committee and to serve as the point of communication for both Ms. Jain and Mr. Dua.

As per a statement issued by The Wire, the reason for establishment of an external committee is that the alleged incident dates back to 1989, when The Wire did not exist. “Yet both Ms Jain and Mr Dua, denied the charges, are entitled to have the matter examined impartially and competently,” it says.

On October 14, in a Facebook post, Ms. Jain had named Mr. Dua, accusing him of demeaning her and cracking lewd jokes during a job interview, and stalking her. She is now learned to have formally consented to the committee on October 18, and has agreed to submit her complaint by October 26.

Apology for trivialising allegations

The founding editors of The Wire have also issued a statement apologising for the manner in which the allegation was trivialised in Episode 318 of Mr. Dua's programme Jan Gan Man Ki Baat: Rafale Deal and Rising Fuel Prices.

In the episode, Mr. Dua had responded to Mr. Jain’s allegations in a trivialising and crass manner. The Wire has now removed the recording from its platforms, and has instead included the statement in its report on Mr. Jain’s allegations.

In their statement, Siddharth Varadarajan, Sidharth Bhatia and MK Venu also stated that Mr. Dua’s show will now remain suspended for the duration of the external committee's probe into the sexual harassment allegations.

Their statement further addresses several other questions, such as those pertaining to the claims that The Wire endorsed Mr. Dua’s claims, in his show, that“keechad (muck)" has been flung on him.

The statement reads: “It would be unfair and inaccurate to suggest this movement, in general is about mudslinging. Such a view runs totally counter to The Wire’s editorial position. His programme went up without any editorial filter and was a major failure of oversight at our end. Some comments he made at the start of the programme about the MeToo movement as a diversion were edited out later, as soon as they were brought to our notice.”

It adds that it does not agree with Mr. Dua’s dismissal of the #Metoo movement, stating, “The Wire’s support for the MeToo movement is clear from its continuing reportage and its editorial. The first, detailed account by a journalist of her experience at the Asian Age working under M.J. Akbar was published by The Wire.

Next Story