Article 370 Case : Live Updates From Supreme Court [Day 11]
LIVELAW NEWS NETWORK
28 Aug 2023 5:02 AM GMT
Live Updates
- 28 Aug 2023 7:02 AM GMT
CJI: Employment under State govt is specifically provided under Art 16(1)..so while on the one hand Art 16(1) was preserved, 35A directly took away that fundamental right & granted immunity to any challenge on the ground that it would deprive you of a fundamental right under 16.
- 28 Aug 2023 7:01 AM GMT
CJI: Though Part III is applicable, when you introduce A 35A, you take away 3 fundamental rights- Article 16(1), right to acquire immovable property which was then a fundamental right under 19(1)(f), A 31, & settlement in the state which was a fundamental right under 19(1)(e)
- 28 Aug 2023 7:01 AM GMT
CJI: See the 1954 order. It applied entirety of Part III (fundamental rights) and so A 16, 19 applied to J&K. Now, you bring in Article 35A which creates an exception under 3 areas: employment under state govt, acquisition of immovable properties, and settlement in the state.