story

The Gauhati High Court recently dismissed a revision petition filed by a husband calling for original medical documents of the wife in a pending divorce case, wherein he had claimed that the wife had epilepsy and had misbehaved with him which amounted to mental cruelty. The division bench comprising Justice Michael Zothankhuma and Justice Sanjeev Kumar Sharma observed:“...the fact remains...

Your free access to Live Law has expired
Please Subscribe for unlimited access to Live Law Archives, Weekly/Monthly Digest, Exclusive Notifications, Comments, Ad Free Version, Petition Copies, Judgement/Order Copies.

The Gauhati High Court recently dismissed a revision petition filed by a husband calling for original medical documents of the wife in a pending divorce case, wherein he had claimed that the wife had epilepsy and had misbehaved with him which amounted to mental cruelty. 

The division bench comprising Justice Michael Zothankhuma and Justice Sanjeev Kumar Sharma observed:

“...the fact remains that epilepsy is a neurological disorder. It is not a mental or psychopathic disorder. It should also be noted that just because a person has epilepsy does not mean that the person is cruel. Cruelty and mental cruelty would have to be decided on the basis of specific instances to be proved by the person making the allegation, against the person who committed acts of cruelty.”

The Court was hearing a revision petition filed by the husband seeking setting aside of orders dated August 02, 2025 and June 12, 2026 passed by the Family Court in pending divorce proceedings. 

The Petitioner's case was that the petitioner and the respondent-wife married on July 15, 2021. However, it was contended by the petitioner that he did not have a copy of the marriage certificate between himself and the respondent-wife.

It was submitted that the petitioner came to learn sometime in December, 2022 that the respondent was suffering from epilepsy and was under constant medical attention. He further submitted that the respondent had gone for treatment to Kochi and due to her epilepsy, she behaved very badly with him, which amounted to mental cruelty.

Therefore, the petitioner submitted an application under Sections 13(1)(ia) and 13(1)(iii) of the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955, which was registered as F.C. (Civil) Case No. 826/2024, seeking dissolution of marriage between the parties by a decree of divorce. The case is pending before the mentioned Family Court.

It was petitioner's submission that on coming to know that the respondent was suffering from epilepsy and was under constant medical attention, the complete medical documents pertaining to the illness and treatment of the respondent were required, to enable the petitioner to lead appropriate evidence in support of his case for divorce, to prove mental cruelty and also to prove that the respondent- wife was having a mental disorder.

The petitioner had filed a petition praying for a direction to produce the original marriage certificate as well as the medical documents pertaining to the epilepsy suffered by the respondent, however, the Family Court, vide the impugned order dated June 12, 2026, rejected the said petition.

Thus, the petitioner prayed before the High Court to set aside the said impugned order.

The Court noted:

“A perusal of the impugned order dated 02.08.2025 shows that the learned Family Court had passed an order in terms of the prayer made by the petitioner herein and in terms of the order dated 12.06.2026, the respondent has produced the original marriage certificate. As such, there is no reason for the petitioner to have challenged the order dated 02.08.2025.”

The Court further observed that with regard to the impugned order dated June 12, 2026, it is seen that the petitioner had submitted the medical documents of the respondent and as such, calling for the original documents was not required at that stage.

It was noted by the Court that it does not find any infirmity with the impugned order dated June 12, 2026 passed by the Family Court, when the petitioner has photocopies of the same.

“As such, when the petitioner has got the photocopies of the medical documents of the respondent and as the learned Family Court has held that the petitioner has the right to call any person under whom the respondent was undergoing treatment, this Court does not find any reason to interfere with the impugned order dated 12.06.2026, as no prejudice can be said to be caused to the petitioner, unless he takes a stand that the contents of the medical documents he has in his possession were false,” the Court said.

The Court further held that the impugned order dated June 12, 2026 has not rejected the prayer of the petitioner, for directing the respondent to submit the original medical documents at present. The Family Court has only held that calling for the original documents was not required at this stage.

“We do not find any reason to come to a different view. As such, we do not find any ground to interfere with the impugned order dated 12.06.2026,” the Court held.

Thus, the Court dismissed the revision petition.

Tags: