Workman Can't Seek Change Of Date Of Birth After Accepting Retirement And Pensionary Benefits: Gauhati High Court
The Gauhati High Court has held that an employee cannot belatedly dispute his date of birth after accepting retirement and pensionary benefits without objection. The Court set aside an Industrial Tribunal's award granting service benefits to a tea estate worker who challenged his retirement date nearly three years after superannuation, despite having accepted retirement benefits...
The Gauhati High Court has held that an employee cannot belatedly dispute his date of birth after accepting retirement and pensionary benefits without objection.
The Court set aside an Industrial Tribunal's award granting service benefits to a tea estate worker who challenged his retirement date nearly three years after superannuation, despite having accepted retirement benefits and post-retirement employment.
Justice Devashis Baruah, observed, "In the opinion of this Court, the learned Industrial Tribunal failed to take note of these vital aspects of the matter, which touches on the principles of estoppel."
The observation came in a writ petition filed by M/s Kalline Tea Estate challenging a 2016 award passed by the Industrial Tribunal, Cachar, Silchar. The Tribunal had held that the workman's date of birth was October 31, 1956, and that he was entitled to benefits as an employee till October 31, 2014, instead of June 30, 2008.
The workman was appointed as a daily-rated permanent worker in 1981 and was subsequently appointed as Sardar, driver and later upgraded to Artisan Grade-B. His year of birth was recorded as 1950 in the PF nomination form.
On June 2, 2008, the management informed him that he would be superannuated on June 30, 2008. He accepted gratuity, provident fund dues and other pensionary benefits, besides accepting post-retirement employment on a six-monthly basis.
In December 2011, he raised a dispute claiming that his date of birth was October 31, 1956, and that he ought to have retired on October 31, 2014.
The management submitted that the workman had accepted his superannuation and pensionary benefits and could not thereafter raise a dispute regarding his date of birth.
The workman's legal representatives, however, submitted that the PF nomination form had not been proved and that his driving licence and insurance policy showed his date of birth as October 31, 1956. They further contended that the High Court ought not to interfere with the Tribunal's award unless there was perversity on the face of the record.
The High Court, after perusing the records of the Industrial Tribunal, noted that the workman had been informed of his superannuation on June 2, 2008, but had not challenged it at that stage. He accepted gratuity, pensionary benefits, provident fund dues and post-retirement employment.
The Court observed, "It is well settled that if a particular date of birth is entered in the Service Register, a change sought for cannot be entertained at the fag end of the service, after accepting the same to be correct during the entire service career."
The Court further observed, "The Workman not only accepted the gratuity, the pensionary benefits as well as the pension, but also accepted an order of re-employment, i.e. an appointment post-superannuation, which would be reviewed on a six-monthly basis."
The Court also noted that the workman had stated in his cross-examination that he had not submitted any certificate concerning his date of birth at the time of his appointments and subsequent upgradation.
It further took note of the Staff Register Details showing his date of birth as October 31, 1956, but observed that the document had not been adduced as evidence before the Industrial Tribunal.
Referring to the Supreme Court's decision in The General Manager, M/s Barsua Iron Ore Mines v. The Vice President, United Mines Mazdoor Union and Others, the High Court found that the present case was factually similar, as the workman had accepted his date of superannuation, received pensionary benefits and accepted re-employment before raising the dispute.
The Court observed, "Factually, the present case is similar inasmuch as the Workman's date of birth was recorded as 1950 in the PF Nomination Form. On 02.06.2008, the Workman was duly informed that he would superannuate on 30.06.2008. The Workman accepted the said date and took the pensionary benefits, which includes the gratuity and the provident fund."
The Court further held, "Under such circumstances, the findings so arrived at by the learned Industrial Tribunal merely on the basis of not proving the PF Nomination Paper and overlooking the conduct of the Workman have led to perversity in the impugned Award dated 02.03.2016. Accordingly, the impugned Award cannot be sustained in law."
The High Court accordingly set aside and quashed the Industrial Tribunal's award and disposed of the writ petition with no order as to costs.