Click the Play button to listen to article
story

The Gauhati High Court has upheld the rejection of a liquor shop bidder's technical bid, holding that a site plan prepared by an Architect does not satisfy the tender requirement of certification by an Engineer.Justice Arun Dev Choudhury, observed, "Therefore, the petitioner has not merely failed to submit a document in a particular form or particular mode. The document relied upon by her...

Your free access to Live Law has expired
Please Subscribe for unlimited access to Live Law Archives, Weekly/Monthly Digest, Exclusive Notifications, Comments, Ad Free Version, Petition Copies, Judgement/Order Copies.

The Gauhati High Court has upheld the rejection of a liquor shop bidder's technical bid, holding that a site plan prepared by an Architect does not satisfy the tender requirement of certification by an Engineer.

Justice Arun Dev Choudhury, observed, "Therefore, the petitioner has not merely failed to submit a document in a particular form or particular mode. The document relied upon by her does not satisfy the substantive requirement prescribed by the tender."

The observation came in a writ petition filed by Renu Dangoria challenging the rejection of her technical bid submitted pursuant to a Notice Inviting Tender (NIT), for settlement of an India Made Foreign Liquor (IMFL) Retail Off Licence for the Shop.

The Scrutiny Committee rejected her bid on the ground that the site plan submitted was not certified by an Engineer, while the bid of another respondent, MPD Services, was accepted.

The petitioner contended that the Checklist of Bidder Eligibility Criteria in Technical Bid (Checklist) could not be treated as prescribing an essential condition of certification by an Engineer, as Clause 6 of the tender document did not specifically refer to it.

She further submitted that the site plan prepared by an Architect satisfied the condition. She also questioned the acceptance of the successful bidder's bid, contending that the Checklist had not been uploaded online and was produced only in hard copy, contrary to Clause 10 of the tender document.

The Excise Department and the successful bidder submitted that the Checklist formed part of the bid document and specifically prescribed a site plan certified by an Engineer. They argued that the petitioner's site plan was prepared by an Architect and was not certified by an Engineer.

The High Court noted that Clause 6 did not state that the Technical Bid would consist only of the documents specifically enumerated therein.

It held that the Checklist formed part of the bid document and expressly prescribed a site plan certified by an Engineer as a bidder eligibility criterion.

The Court observed: "A tender document must be read as a whole, and its different provisions must be harmoniously construed. No provision can be isolated from the remaining provisions to render another express requirement in the same tender document meaningless."

The Court further noted that the requirement of certification by an Engineer related directly to the suitability and identification of the proposed site.

It observed, "In the present case, the stipulation that the site plan should be certified by an engineer is expressed in clear terms and relates directly to the suitability and identification of the proposed site. The tender condition even prescribes the minimum area of such proposed shop. Therefore, the site cannot be reduced to a mere formality."

Regarding the successful bidder's failure to upload the Checklist online, the Court found that the certification had been uploaded, while the Checklist was submitted along with the hard copy.

It held that there was no substantive eligibility defect in the successful bidder's bid and that the alleged irregularity could not be a ground to interfere with the Scrutiny Committee's decision.

The Court also held that the petitioner could not invoke Article 14 of the Constitution to claim a right to an eligibility status which she herself did not possess.

The Court observed: "The principle of equality requires the tendering authority to apply the stipulated condition uniformly. It does not entitle an otherwise ineligible bidder to acceptance merely because another bidder is alleged to have received an undue advantage; more particularly, in the present case, the mandate to upload Annexure-C is not discernible from the bid documents."

Referring to the limitations on judicial review in contractual and tender matters, the Court observed, "The court does not sit as an appellate authority over the tender committee's assessment. Interference is warranted where the decision is shown to be arbitrary, irrational, mala fide, perverse, or contrary to the tender conditions. At the same time, the court cannot rewrite the tender condition or substitute its own view regarding the equivalence of a qualification expressly prescribed by the tender."

The Court found that the reasons recorded by the Scrutiny Committee for rejecting the petitioner's bid directly related to the tender requirement and that the decision could not be characterised as arbitrary or based on any extraneous consideration.

The Court held, "On the material placed on record, the rejection of the petitioner's technical bid cannot be said to be illegal, arbitrary or perverse. The scrutiny committee acted on an express requirement contained in the tender document and rejected the petitioner's bid for failure to satisfy it."

Accordingly, finding no ground to interfere with the Scrutiny Committee's decision in exercise of its power of judicial review, the High Court dismissed the writ petition. Parties were directed to bear their own costs.

Tags: