Agricultural Labourer Travelling In Trailer To Load/ Unload Produce Not Gratuitous Passenger: Gauhati High Court Upholds Insurers' Liability
The Gauhati High Court has held that an agricultural labourer travelling in a trailer for loading and unloading agricultural produce cannot be treated as a gratuitous passenger under an agricultural liability insurance policy.Justice Kardak Ete, observed, "The claimant was not travelling in the trailer as a passenger unconnected with its use. He was travelling as a labourer along with the...
The Gauhati High Court has held that an agricultural labourer travelling in a trailer for loading and unloading agricultural produce cannot be treated as a gratuitous passenger under an agricultural liability insurance policy.
Justice Kardak Ete, observed, "The claimant was not travelling in the trailer as a passenger unconnected with its use. He was travelling as a labourer along with the jute and jute sticks which were being transported for the purpose of loading and unloading the same. Thus, his presence in the trailer was directly connected with the agricultural use of the vehicle."
The observation came in an appeal filed by United India Insurance Company Ltd. against a 2016 judgment and award passed by the Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, Darrang, awarding ₹5,30,000 as compensation to Md. Amsher Ali for injuries sustained in a motor vehicle accident.
The Tribunal had directed the insurers of the tractor and trailer to pay the compensation in equal proportion, along with interest at 6% per annum.
The claimant was travelling as a labourer in a tractor and trailer carrying jute and jute sticks on September 14, 2010, when the tractor driver hit an electric post. A live high-voltage electric wire fell upon the tractor and trailer, causing grievous injuries to the claimant. During treatment, his left leg was amputated below the knee, and he sustained burn injuries to his right hand.
The appellant-insurer contended that the accident occurred due to the rash and negligent driving of the tractor and that the claimant was a gratuitous passenger whose risk was not covered under the "Agricultural Liability Only" policy. It further submitted that no premium had been paid for covering persons travelling in the trailer.
The insurer of the tractor, however, submitted that the claimant was travelling in the trailer as a labourer for loading and unloading agricultural produce and that his presence was incidental to its agricultural purpose. It was further submitted that the tractor and trailer were separately registered and insured vehicles and that the appellant could not avoid liability merely because the accident was caused by the negligence of the tractor driver.
The High Court, upon considering the evidence on record, found that the claimant was travelling in the trailer along with agricultural produce and was engaged as a labourer for loading and unloading the same.
The Court opined that the evidence of the claimant and another witness “has not been materially shaken in cross-examination. There is also no evidence on record to establish that the claimant was travelling in the trailer as a gratuitous passenger having no connection with the goods being carried therein.”
"In such circumstances, the learned Tribunal cannot be said to have committed any error in holding that the claimant came within the purview of the agricultural liability covered by the policy,” the Court held.
As regards the contention that the accident occurred solely due to the negligence of the tractor driver, the Court noted that the claimant had sustained injuries while travelling in the trailer, which was separately registered and insured.
The Court observed, "In the facts as found by the learned Tribunal, the mere fact that the immediate cause of the accident was the negligence of the tractor driver does not answer the separate question as to whether the claimant's risk was covered under the policy issued in respect of the trailer."
The Court also rejected the submission that no premium had been paid for covering the claimant's risk.
It held, "His presence in the trailer was thus essentially connected with the agricultural use of the vehicle and cannot be treated as that of a gratuitous passenger. The learned Tribunal, having regard to the aforesaid facts and the nature of the policy, has rightly held that the claimant was covered under the agricultural liability policy."
Finding no perversity, illegality or error of law warranting interference with the Tribunal's judgment and award, the High Court dismissed the appeal and affirmed the compensation of ₹5,30,000, along with interest at 6% per annum, payable by both insurers in equal proportion.