Click the Play button to listen to article

The Allahabad High Court has held that the Uttar Pradesh Gangsters and Anti-Social Activities (Prevention) Act, 1986, remains operative despite the Supreme Court's recent observation declaring the Act 'stillborn'.

The High Court clarified that the Supreme Court in Shiv Pratap Singh Alias Chinu Versus State of U.P & Ors had not declared the Act unconstitutional and that an earlier Full Bench judgment of the HC in Ashok Kumar Dixit vs State Of U.P. And Anr. 1989 upholding its validity continued to bind it.

However, to prevent routine invocation of the Act, a Bench of Justice Chandra Dhari Singh and Justice Tarun Saxena issued 12 directions/guidelines to authorities to demonstrate independent application of mind before preparing and approving a gang chart.

While doing so, the Court quashed the FIR registered by the Saharanpur Police in connection with an alleged 2021 country liquor excise evasion case qua 4 petitioners [Pranay Aneja, Ashwani Upadhyay, Upendra Govind Rao and Ravindra Kishor].

Case in brief

Briefly put, the FIR under the 1986 Act was lodged against 16 named persons on the allegations that officers and employees of a licensed distillery, along with a transporter, wholesale licensees and certain excise officials, removed liquor twice on a single pass by using duplicate bar codes.

It was alleged that they manipulated records and thereby evaded excise duty.

It was further alleged that the irregularities involved manipulation of passes, registers and other records and that there were discrepancies found in the electronic records maintained in connection with the transportation and sale of liquor.

The informant in the case was an Assistant Excise Commissioner. An official team intercepted a truck near the factory and seized records, including passes, bar codes, registers, software entries and invoices. Statements recorded during a raid also formed part of the material.

High Court's observations

Challenging the FIR, the petitioners moved the High Court, wherein the bench noted that the allegations, if proved, could constitute cheating, forgery and evasion of duty.

It noted that these offences were already being prosecuted in the underlying case. However, they did not disclose the ingredients of a gang under Section 2(b) of the Act read with Rule 3 of the 2021 Rules.

The bench noted that no violence, threat, intimidation or coercion was attributed to the petitioners.

The Bench said that merely listing an activity covered by Section 2(b) was insufficient and that the activity must also involve the means and object prescribed by the provision and the Rules.

The Court also questioned the timing of the invocation of the Act. It noted that while the alleged incident occurred on March 3, 2021, the gang chart was prepared on December 1, 2025.

It also noted that no activity falling within Section 2(b) was alleged against the petitioners during the intervening period.

It clarified that it was not recording a finding of mala fides, but said the sequence of events required the State to demonstrate, through contemporaneous records, that the decision to invoke the Act rested on genuine reasons.

The Court also found serious defects in the preparation and approval of the gang chart under Rules 5(3)(a), 16 and 17.

It noted that no minutes of the mandatory joint meeting of the competent authorities were produced before it.

The only document furnished was a copy of signatures in a register, forwarded after the petitions had been filed and interim protection granted. It did not disclose what material was discussed or how the individual cases were considered.

The bench noted that the District Magistrate's approval referred to a 'consensus' among officers, but the same did not identify the relevant clause of Section 2(b), the alleged means of violence or coercion, the object, or the individual role of any accused.

The Bench further found that endorsements by intermediate authorities were identical.

Referring to the Supreme Court's judgment in Vinod Bihari Lal v. State of UP, it observed that a formula copied at every level amounted to a "cyclostyle reproduction" and could not demonstrate independent application of mind.

In the present case, the bench noted that the chart was prepared against 27 persons within eight days, with the FIR registered at 11:15 pm on the date of approval.

The Court also noted that 20 persons had been added beyond the nine names recommended by the SIT, without any recorded explanation.

Against this backdrop, holding that the statutory satisfaction required under the Rules was a jurisdictional condition and its absence went to the root of the proceedings, the Bench issued 12 directions for future cases. These include:

1. Authorities must record, for each person, the specific clause of Section 2(b) invoked, the alleged means and object, and supporting material.

2. Satisfaction must be individualised; collective or identical entries will not suffice.

3. Where the base case is already charge-sheeted or pending trial, reasons must explain why ordinary prosecution is inadequate.

4. The gang chart must mention the date of the last alleged act and explain any delay in invoking the Act.

5. It must disclose the status of base cases, relevant judicial or regulatory orders and any investigating agency recommendation.

6. Joint meetings must be documented through minutes recording the material considered and reasons concerning each person.

7. Every forwarding and approving authority must record its own satisfaction, in its own words, with dates.

8. No FIR can be registered before the approval process and meeting minutes are complete.

9. Only activities falling within Section 2(b) can be counted as base cases; other cases may be listed separately as criminal history.

10. Where public servants are included, authorities must explain why the Gangsters Act, rather than departmental or anti-corruption remedies, is appropriate.

11. In challenges to such FIRs, the State must produce the original gang chart, meeting register and material considered.

12. In cases of non-compliance, the judgment must be sent to the Chief Secretary and Additional Chief Secretary (Home) for examination of the authorities' conduct and corrective measures.

The Court clarified that the Gangsters Act is an exceptional measure and cannot become an alternative to ordinary criminal prosecution merely because the underlying allegations are serious.

Against this backdrop, the bench allowed the 4 writ petitions.

However, it clarified that the proceedings in the underlying excise case, PMLA proceedings and departmental action against Ravindra Kishor would continue independently.

The other persons named in the FIR were left at liberty to pursue remedies available in law.

The Registrar was directed to circulate the judgment to District Magistrates, Police Commissioners and senior police officers across Uttar Pradesh.

Senior Counsel Purnendu Chakravarty, assisted by Advocate Rishabh Chauhan and Advocates Atul Khaneja, Subir Lal and Ram Prakash appeared for the petitioners


Tags: