Petitioner Cites Pegasus Issue In Supreme Court To Argue Against Allowing WhatsApp Payment Services

The controversy regarding snooping of WhatsApp users using Israeli spy software 'Pegasus' found a mention in the Supreme Court on Wednesday.The 'Pegasus-Whatsapp' issue was referred to by Senior Advocate Krishnan Venugopal to argue that the system of WhatsApp was not secure and reliable so as to allow it to launch payment services.Venugopal was appearing for Binoy Viswam, Rajya Sabha MP belonging to Communist Party of India(CPI), who has filed a writ petition in the Supreme Court seeking to direct the Reserve Bank of Inda(RBI) and the National Payments Corporation of India(NPCI) to ensure date protection of various Unified Payments Interface (UPI) platforms.Referring to Venugopal's submission, the Chief Justice of India told Senior Advocate Kapil Sibal, the counsel of WhatsApp : "Mr. Krishnan Venugopal has made a serious allegation that your system (WhatsApp) can be hacked by something called 'Pegasus'".Sibal vehemently denied the allegation as "absolutely baseless". He submitted that such an allegation was not there in the writ petition and that the same was a baseless oral submission made across the bar.Venugopal retorted by saying that the Pegasus issue has been covered by several newspapers.CJI then told Venugopal that the submission should be made on affidavit. In response, Venugopal asserted that the submission is there on the affidavit.The petition refers to the Pegasus controversy in paragraph 22 as follows :"...after the acquisition of Whatsapp by Facebook in 2014, Whatsapp has also suffered from and been accused of several privacy and security breaches as well. The biggest breach among those was the hacking of the devices and accounts of several Indians by the software named "Pegasus" developed by Israeli organization NSO. The spyware was activated on an individual's device by merely a missed voice call on the application, which highlights the vulnerability of respondent no.7's (Whatsapp) platform"The Pegasus issue came to light last year after Whatsapp filed a suit in the US against the Israeli company alleging that it hacked the Whatsapp servers to install malwares on the accounts of nearly 1400 users for conducting surveillance.The issue found echoes in India as the list of targeted individuals allegedly contained several prominent activists, journalist, lawyers and academicians who have voiced dissent against the Indian government.When the subject was raised in the Rajya Sabha last year, the Union IT Minister Ravi Shankar Prasad refused to give a direct answer to the query whether the Indian Government hired the services of Pegasus to snoop on individuals.The Minister said "no unauthorized interception has been done, to the best of my knowledge".Whatsapp Spyware : Union IT Minister Evades Question In Rajya Sabha On Whether Govt Sought Pegasus ServicesMajor issues with UPI platforms, petitioner submits in SCThe PIL filed by the CPI MP through Advocate Sriram Parakkat seeks for "the protection of fundamental right to privacy of millions of Indian citizens who are using Unified Payments Interface (UPI)".Krishnan Venugopal, appearing for Binoy Viswam, submitted that there are three or four major issues with the UPI systems of Amazon, Google, Facebook and Whatsapp.As far as Whatsapp is concerned, there is no system for 'two-factor authentication', he said. Whatsapp is using the same platform of the messenger service to allow payments. Another issue raised by the counsel was "data localization". According to him, the problem with Whatsapp, Amazon & Google was that when they allow payment to happen, data goes abroad. He submitted that the RBI has to respond on whether it is proper for the data of Indians to go abroad without any formal protection.He further submitted that critical financial data is being allowed by the RBI to be accessed by companies abroad without any regulations or guidelines. This is violation of Privacy judgment as a citizen's data is being grossly misused by these companies which use the aggregated data for their revenue generation through advertisements and promotions.Venugopal argued that the data is being shared with the parent companies in violation of the NPCI guidelines. The data is being processed by the infrastructure of the parent company.The bench, also comprising Justices AS Bopanna and V Ramasubramanian, asked the National Payments Corporation of India(NPCI) to reply to the petition and adjourned the hearing till the last week of January 2021.The petition submits that RBI and NPCI "have permitted the three members of 'Big Four Tech Giants' i.e. Amazon, Google and Facebook/WhatsApp (Beta phase) to participate in the UPI ecosystem without much scrutiny and inspite of blatant violations of UPI guidelines and RBI Regulations".This conduct of the two authorities, submits the plea, invariably puts the sensitive financial data of Indian users at huge risk, especially in light of the fact that the Big Four Tech Giants have been "continuously accused of abusing dominance,...

Petitioner Cites Pegasus Issue In Supreme Court To Argue Against Allowing WhatsApp Payment Services

LIVELAW NEWS NETWORK

Tags