Allahabad High Court Releases Man Caught Filming Hearing After He Tenders Apology; Courtroom Mobile Phone Ban To Continue
The Allahabad High Court on Friday directed the release of a man who was taken into custody a day earlier for recording court proceedings on his mobile phone without permission.
Pursuant to the Court's November 19 order, he appeared before the Court at 10 AM on Friday and tendered an unconditional apology and undertook not to record proceedings in future.
Taking his apology on record, Justice Vikram D Chauhan dropped the proceedings initiated in connection with the incident and directed that the mobile phone be returned to him after deleting the recording of the court proceedings and resetting the device.
He was also restrained from publishing any such video on social media
However, the single judge clarified that its earlier direction prohibiting litigants from carrying mobile phones into the courtroom would continue.
For the uninitiated, the matter arose on November 19, when the Court noticed that a person named Raj Kulshrestha was recording the hearing on his mobile phone without permission.
When questioned, he admitted he was recording the proceedings without the Court's permission but could not explain the purpose.
After the Bench Secretary took his mobile phone into custody and opened it, the Court found that 3 videos of the proceedings had been recorded.
The Court noted that Kulshrestha had no case listed before it and was carrying a pass issued by the Registry which permitted access only to the Advocates' Chamber.
The Court then directed that he be taken into custody and produced before the Chief Judicial Magistrate, Prayagraj, and asked him to explain why the unauthorised recording should not be treated as interference with the administration of justice.
When the matter was taken up again on Friday (November 20), advocates Nitish Kumar Soni and Bhanu Pratap Seth also appeared before the Court. Kulshrestha had entered the courtroom on a pass issued in connection with them.
Kulshrestha was also produced before the Court in police custody, while Kuldeep Batra, the petitioner in the underlying case, was present.
Advocate Soni informed the Court that he had been out of station on the previous day and had sent Seth to seek an adjournment. He tendered an unconditional apology for the incident and regretted the inconvenience caused to the Court.
On being asked why he had not appeared on November 19 despite the Court's direction, Seth stated that he was frightened and, therefore, could not appear alone.
Kulshrestha also tendered an unconditional apology and gave an undertaking that he would maintain the decorum of the Court in future and would not record court proceedings.
The Court also took note of the issue concerning the entry pass carried by Batra. It recorded that Batra had entered the courtroom using a pass meant for access to the Advocates' Chamber.
Soni stated that the incorrect pass had been issued due to an error on the part of his office and tendered an unconditional apology in that regard.
In view of these circumstances, and noting that counsel had admitted the mistake, the Court observed that the proceedings could be dropped.
The Court directed that Kulshrestha be released forthwith. However, it specifically clarified that the directions contained in its November 19 order prohibiting litigants from carrying mobile phones into the courtroom would continue.
"The mobile phones may be kept in the office of the concerned Advocate or may be kept somewhere else", the bench said.
Furthermore, the Court also directed that its November 19 order be placed before the Division Bench hearing the suo motu PIL concerning security and protection in all court campuses in Uttar Pradesh, for consideration of measures to ensure that litigants do not carry mobile phones into courtrooms.
In its November 19 order, the Court said that the principle of open justice means that court proceedings are generally open to the public to attend. However, it clarified that this does not amount to a right of "free broadcast" by an unauthorised individual.
It had noted that cases involving individual liberty, child sexual abuse, the CBI, the Enforcement Directorate and MPs/MLAs often involved facts that were not required to be published on social media without judicial determination.
The Court added that the court proceedings are not for entertainment purposes but is a serious business affecting liberty and rights of an individual
"The publishing or recording such judicial proceedings without leave of the Court may have the effect of social media trial without even the final determination in the court proceedings and may adversely affect the court proceedings or the right of litigant. There may be prejudice caused to the persons, whose cases are being listed and argued before this Court. The victims may also have to face social media stigma, if their facts or harassment is uploaded on the digital network," the Court remarked.