BHU Hospital Medicine Purchase Irregularities: Allahabad High Court Seeks Enquiry Reports, Says VC's Inaction Can't Be Ignored
| HC orders BHU to preserve all medicine procurement records, including tender documents, stock registers, bills and payment vouchers.
The Allahabad High Court has called for a response from the Banaras Hindu University (BHU) over alleged large-scale irregularities and embezzlement of public funds in the purchase of medicines, surgical items, and medical equipment for the hospital attached to the University.
A Bench of Justice Chandra Dhari Singh and Justice Tarun Saxena observed that the allegations, if found proved, disclose serious financial irregularities in the purchase of medicines in a public hospital, directly affecting public health.
The Court further observed that the inaction on the part of the Vice-Chancellor, despite the submission of multiple enquiry reports, "cannot be ignored at this stage".
The Bench was hearing a Criminal Writ-Public Interest Litigation filed by Amit Kumar Mishra and 2 others who seek an independent investigation into the alleged irregularities and embezzlement of public funds.
The plea also seeks action against the officers found responsible.
According to the submissions made on behalf of the petitioners, several enquiry committees constituted by the University had submitted their reports in August and September 2026, pointing out alleged gross irregularities, inflated pricing, purchases without tenders and procurement of substandard items.
However, it was submitted that no action had allegedly been taken by the Vice-Chancellor.
It was further apprised to the bench that the enquiry reports had not been made available in the public domain and had been deliberately suppressed.
The petitioners also claimed that repeated representations made to the Vice-Chancellor and the State Government had remained unattended.
It was contended that in view of the inaction of the highest authorities of the University and the involvement of some Senior Officers, an probe by the State Police would not inspire confidence.
They accordingly sought a direction for an independent agency, such as the Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI) or a Special Investigation Team (SIT), to conduct a preliminary enquiry.
The counsel appearing for BHU opposed the writ petition.
After considering the submissions and the material on record, the High Court observed thus:
"The allegations, if found proved, disclose serious financial irregularities in the purchase of medicines in a public hospital, directly affecting public health. The inaction on the part of the Vice-Chancellor, despite submission of multiple enquiry reports, cannot be ignored at this stage."
Against this backdrop, the Court directed the Vice-Chancellor/Registrar of the University to place on record, by way of a short affidavit, all enquiry committee reports relating to the alleged purchase irregularities, along with the action-taken report, if any, within 10 days.
The University has also been directed to preserve all records pertaining to the purchase, tender, supply and stock of medicines, including stock registers, payment vouchers and bills.
The Court specifically directed that these records shall not be destroyed or tampered with in any manner until the next date of hearing.
The Bench further directed that the Vice-Chancellor/Registrar shall remain present before the Court on the next date of listing if the enquiry reports and affidavit are not filed within the stipulated period, for further assistance.
The State respondents have also been directed to file their response.
The matter has been listed as a fresh case on December 11.
Senior Advocate Samir Sharma, assisted by Advocate Himanshu Agrawal, appeared on behalf of the petitioners.
Advocate Pooja Agarwal appeared on behalf of BHU, respondent nos.3 to 7.
AGA appeared for the State-respondents.