Sibal: If there's an offense, it has to be reported to the state. How can all this happen in an Art 32 petition?

J Mishra: It has happened there, not in a writ petition

Sibal: They can't ask for investigation in a writ, they have to ask the state to probe. Why should the HC not hear the matter? It's not disabled to hear this.

SG: My objection to matters of arguments being debated elsewhere is not only qua Mr. Sibal...it's against others also...

Sibal: My ld. friend should have no objection as he knows that's not the law. Judgment is a public property, it can be discussed.

SG: There's narrative building

Singhvi (for state and DGP): We have serious objection to maintainability of this petition. If notice is issued, it should be made clear that it's subject to our maintainability objection. ED walk-in allowed only in exceptional circumstances - where it is virtually remediless. I object to forum shopping also. Identical prayers before HC - broadly.