J Nagarathna: see the first para of J Jaswant Singh opinion.

Hegde: reads it, I am not joining issue

J Narasimha: we are sitting in nine Mr Hegde

Hegde: clear view of six may commend itself for your lordships acceptance over what was slightly muddy

J Datta: in the system where we cover, even four can overrule five. In Teen Murthi, which is five judge, we have to see numerical strength of the bench. Therefore, AMU is taken as seven even though 4 was on one side and 3 was one side. Don't take this and say there is muddy and we have to clear it.