Singhvi: your lordships under Article 143 is binding, a matter is referred, the law will change for future. Suppose, in appropriate matter, it is referred..otherwise kindly consider advisiory jurisdiction, it becomes intra-court appeals

J Nath: this is not right, you are presuming we will null the two judge judgment

CJI: show us one judgment where in a division bench, a reference is not tenable. We are not deciding the issue whether tamil nadu is correct or not

Singhvi: in the event, the answers is not consistent

CJI: we are not concerned with that