Jaising: one factual important-constituent assembly debated for 4 days on articles 25 and 26. we are on 10th day, like we are a constituent assembly to do the job which was left uncomplete. they are asking you to overrule shirur mutt and devaru-but in reference, you can't do that. it can be overruled in proceed prescribed by law only when per incuriam.

J Bagchi: we can declare the law from what is different from the laws decided.

Jaising: i don't dispute your jurisdiciton but i will dispute your binding effect-it will only be an opinion

J Bagchi: we can always interplay articles 25 and 26 and trangulation from what devaru and others understood

Jaising: i am only dispute the binding effect because it doesn't come from a cause before you. J Nagarathna reminds me again and again about the cause of action

J Bagchi: it has been decided by the former CJI. reference form has been decided, it has to be decided on substance and merit

Jasing: i am on the nature of opinion to be delivered