Jaising: what is the question we are deciding? discretion not to entertain is a different matter but what was said that u can't decide the questions of religions because you are not a theologian. if you are not, call a theologian.

J Nagarathna: question is can court sit in judgment on conscience

Jaising: there is a dissenting judgment where the judge tells us what is conscience- no one can be called for the bar to account for their conscience- to not be called for holding a certain view. in exercise of that view, if you violate my right I will say don't violate with the help of practice.

in India, there is nothing called a thought crime-i can be sitting at home and think I wish I was death-can you file a suit or criminal case? its the execution.