Singhvi: This is no longer about dogs, humans. It's about constitutional principles and limits of constitutional powers. According to us, my lord has seen statutes and rules, which heavily occupy the area

J Mehta: Exhaustively argued by Mr. Gopal S, that our order was contrary to Rules

Singhvi: Rules form a seamless web. This Court has held that such a web deters judicial intervention. For intervention, there has to be a legislative gap. [Citing a 2014 judgment] In case there's inaction by executive, court has obligation to enforce law. If there's vacuum, court can issue guidelines till legislature passes a law. There are many restrictions on your lordships. Till very recently, Vishaka guidelines operated without a law. For 20 years. It noted that there was a vacuum.