Delhi Consumer Commission Holds Metro Hospital Liable For Ambulance Failure, Awards ₹15 Lakh

  • Delhi Consumer Commission Holds Metro Hospital Liable For Ambulance Failure, Awards ₹15 Lakh
    Listen to this Article

    The Delhi State Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission, comprising President Justice Sangita Dhingra Sehgal and Member (Judicial) Pinki, has held Metro Hospital & Heart Institute guilty of deficiency in service for failing to arrange an adequately equipped ambulance and a qualified doctor to accompany a critically ill patient during his transfer to another hospital.

    The Commission observed that ensuring safe transportation and continuity of medical care is an essential part of a hospital's duty of care.

    Facts:

    The complainant, Suresh Kumar, was suffering from Rheumatic Heart Disease and had undergone Dual Valve Replacement surgery at AIIMS on November 25, 2008.

    On November 13, 2013, he developed acute breathing difficulties and was rushed to Metro Hospital & Heart Institute, New Delhi. Medical investigations revealed an obstruction in his aortic prosthetic valve due to a blood clot. The treating doctor advised hospitalisation and administration of a Streptokinase (STK) injection to dissolve the clot.

    The complainant alleged that the hospital did not adequately explain the risks and complications associated with the injection. On November 15, 2013, his family was informed that he had suffered a stroke, resulting in paralysis on the right side of his body and loss of speech.

    The family further alleged that despite his critical condition, the hospital failed to arrange an adequately equipped ambulance and a doctor for transferring him to another hospital. Consequently, they had to arrange an ambulance themselves, and the patient was shifted without medical supervision.

    Despite subsequent treatment at Vimhans Hospital, AIIMS and Sir Ganga Ram Hospital, the patient continued to suffer from speech impairment, memory loss, reduced mental capacity and physical disability, leaving him dependent on his family.

    Alleging medical negligence and deficiency in service, the complainant filed the present complaint.

    Contentions of the Hospital:

    Metro Hospital denied medical negligence, stating that the patient was treated according to established medical protocols and that written high-risk consent had been obtained before administering Streptokinase. It also maintained that the stroke was a known complication of the treatment and denied delaying the patient's transfer.

    Observation and decision:

    The Commission observed that the treating doctor followed established medical protocols and that stroke was a known complication of Streptokinase treatment. Relying on Martin F. D'Souza v. Mohd. Ishfaq (AIR 2009 SC 2049), the Commission found no medical negligence on the doctor's part.

    However, the Commission held Metro Hospital liable for failing to arrange an adequately equipped ambulance and a qualified medical professional to accompany the patient during transfer. Referring to Balram Prasad v. Kunal Saha & Ors. (Civil Appeal No. 2867 of 2012), it reiterated the higher standard of care expected from premier hospitals.

    Holding the hospital guilty of deficiency in service under the Consumer Protection Act, 1986, the Commission directed Metro Hospital to pay ₹15 lakh as compensation for mental agony and distress, along with ₹50,000 towards litigation costs.

    The hospital was directed to comply within two months, failing which the awarded amount would attract 9% annual interest from the date of filing of the complaint until realisation.

    Case Title :  SURESH KUMAR V. METRO HOSPITAL & HEART INSTITUTE & ORS.Case Number :  CC/1146/2015
    Praveen Mishra

    Praveen Mishra is a Correspondent at LiveLaw. He covers consumer cases and reports on matters from various High Courts. A law graduate, he has been a part of LiveLaw for more than two years.

    Next Story