'Bureaucratic Lethargy': Allahabad High Court Imposes ₹25K Costs On UP Govt For Police Failure To File Chargesheet For Over A Decade

  • Bureaucratic Lethargy: Allahabad High Court Imposes ₹25K Costs On UP Govt For Police Failure To File Chargesheet For Over A Decade

    Litigant cannot be made to suffer indefinitely on account of bureaucratic lethargy and sheer indifference of the police, says HC

    Listen to this Article

    The Allahabad High Court recently imposed costs of ₹25,000 on the Uttar Pradesh Government after Pratapgarh Police failed to file a charge-sheet in a 2015 FIR for over a decade.

    The Court noted that the authorities "woke up from their slumber" only after the complainant approached the Court and the chargesheet was filed only in October 2026.

    A Bench of Justice Abdul Moin and Justice Pramod Kumar Srivastava described the matter as an "alarming state of affairs" and remarked that the manner in which it was handled indicated "gross dereliction of duty".

    "A litigant who knocks on the doors of the justice delivery system cannot be made to suffer indefinitely on account of bureaucratic lethargy and sheer indifference of the police authorities", the Court observed.

    Accordingly, it directed the State Government to pay ₹25,000 to the petitioner as an "exemplary token cost" within four weeks.

    The bench also left it open for the Government to recover the amount from the erring police officials found responsible for the delay.

    Briefly put, the petitioner approached the Court alleging that despite the passage of more than a decade, the police had failed to conclude the investigation or submit a police report before the competent court.

    The bench was apprised that the FIR in question was lodged in March 2015 under Sections 147, 148, 149, 323, 452, 504 and 506 IPC

    During the hearing on September 28, the Additional Government Advocate informed the Court that the charge-sheet had initially been forwarded on April 24, 2015, but certain objections were raised.

    Following further investigation, it was again forwarded on June 10, 2023. However, the case diary was subsequently misplaced and an inquiry was instituted on September 25, 2026.

    The Court noted that the inquiry had been initiated only after notice of the writ petition was given to the Government Advocate on September 22, 2026.

    "It is very surprising that in an FIR of the year 2015, till date, the police report has not been filed and the Station House Officer concerned is also sleeping over the matter and has not taken any action", the Bench observed.

    The Superintendent of Police, Pratapgarh, was directed to personally inquire into the matter and submit an affidavit.

    On October 14, the Court was informed that the misplaced charge-sheet had been traced and filed before the concerned court on October 6, 2026.

    The bench was also apprised that an inquiry into the alleged dereliction of duty by Head Constable Vishnu Kant Singh had also been initiated and a show-cause was notice issued to him on October 9.

    The Court then sought an explanation from the Superintendent of Police as to why exemplary costs should not be imposed, noting that the petitioner had been waiting for justice for 10 years.

    On November 16, the Additional Government Advocate informed the Bench that the concerned court had taken cognizance of the matter on October 14, 2026.

    However, in response to the show-cause notice concerning costs, the SP concerned merely tendered an unconditional apology and stated that the delay had occurred because the case diary and papers had been misplaced by the staff.

    The High Court, however, was not satisfied with the explanation.

    It observed that the FIR had not been taken to its logical conclusion for more than a decade and that the authorities had "abruptly woke up from their slumber" only after the petitioner approached the Court.

    "The charge-sheet, which had purportedly been prepared years ago, was finally submitted before the court concerned only on 06.10.2026. It is therefore apparent that the entire machinery went into motion only under the compelling gaze of this Court", the Bench observed.

    The Court further stated that senior police officials were expected to actively supervise investigations and monitor criminal proceedings within their jurisdiction, rather than waking up only when notices and orders were issued by the Court.

    It also described the response to its show-cause notice as casual.

    Against this backdrop, the bench said that the petitioner was entitled to be compensated for the delay.

    Therefore, it imposed an "exemplary token cost" of ₹25,000 on the State Government. However, it clarified that the State Government could recover the amount from police officials found responsible for the "egregious delay and dereliction of duty".

    The writ petition was accordingly disposed of.

    Case Title :  Chandbabu vs. State Of U.P. Thru. Prin. Secy. Revenue Lko. And 2 Others 2026 LiveLaw (AB) 956CITATION :  2026 LiveLaw (AB) 956
    Sparsh Upadhyay

    Sparsh Upadhyay is an Associate Editor with LiveLaw.

    Next Story