Father's Duty To Educate Child Can't Be Made A Tool For Oppression, Socio-Economic Condition Of Parents Relevant: Allahabad High Court

  • Fathers Duty To Educate Child Cant Be Made A Tool For Oppression, Socio-Economic Condition Of Parents Relevant: Allahabad High Court
    Listen to this Article

    The Allahabad High Court has held that while a father is responsible for educating his child in a good and reputed institution commensurate with his means, that responsibility cannot be made a tool for oppression, and the socio-economic condition of the parents must also be looked into while fixing maintenance and educational expenses under Section 26 of the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955.

    Reducing a father's liability from Rs. 15,000/- to Rs. 12,000/- per month, the Court held that the amount fixed by the Trial Court was not reasonable where the daughter was receiving free education at a Central School and it was the mother who chose to shift her to a private school, without material to show that the earlier school fell short.

    Section 26 of the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955 empowers the court, in any proceeding under the Act, to pass interim orders and make provisions in the decree regarding the custody, maintenance and education of minor children.

    The bench of Justice Prakash Padia and Justice Indrajeet Shukla held,

    “No doubt father being natural guardian is bestowed with the responsibility imparting education in good and repudiated Alma matter commensurate financial and economic viability but same cannot be made a tool for oppression as right to education is a fundamental right but the socio-economic condition of parents are also to be looked into when it comes for adjudication of courts.”

    Appellant and respondent married on 03.05.2014. After eight years, appellant filed a matrimonial petition under Section 13(1)(i-a) of the Act seeking divorce. An application under Section 26 of the Act read with Section 151 CPC was thereafter filed on behalf of the minor daughter through her mother, claiming Rs. 1,00,000/- as one-time expenses and Rs. 35,000/- per month, including Rs. 56,000/- towards admission fees for the Fourth Standard at a school in Greater Noida.

    Appellant opposed the application, pleading that the respondent was a Clerk at a Central School drawing Rs. 60,000/- per month, whereas he was a Clerk at an Inter College drawing Rs. 37,504/- per month and had old ailing parents and an unemployed younger brother to maintain. By order dated 11.08.2023, the Trial Court apportioned the claim, fixing Rs. 20,000/- against the mother and Rs. 15,000/- against the father. This order was challenged by the father in First Appeal.

    Appellant pleaded that the father is the primary natural guardian of a Hindu minor and that his obligation to maintain, including educational expenses, would arise only once custody was transferred to him. It was pleaded that the daughter had been shifted from the Central School, where she was entitled to free education as the single girl child of an employee, merely to torment him.

    Respondent pleaded that having not disputed his liability, the appellant could not question the order, and that the Trial Court had placed the larger share on her. It was pleaded that the appellant had admitted loan instalments of Rs. 21,780/- per month while maintaining a car, and had been evasive about his income and assets.

    The Court held that the contention linking the obligation to maintain with transfer of custody was fallacious, no application for custody having been moved by the father. Relying on Ms. Githa Hariharan & Anr. v. Reserve Bank of India & Anr., it observed that the mother can also act as natural guardian during the lifetime of the father, and that any preference based on gender would be violative of Article 15(3) of the Constitution of India.

    It held that maintaining children is a joint parental obligation and that the mother being gainfully employed did not absolve the father of his duty, her financial capacity being relevant only to each parent's proportionate contribution. The application moved on behalf of the minor through her mother was held maintainable, custody and maintenance being adjudicable at the pre-decree as well as the post-decree stage.

    “The determination of quantum as made by trial Court towards maintenance and educational expenses of a child studying in the Sixth Standard does not appear to be reasonable, particularly when the minor respondent was receiving free education at a Central School and it was the respondent who opted to change the school, without placing any cogent material to demonstrate that the erstwhile school was not meeting the requisite educational standards.”

    Noting that the appellant was residing in rented accommodation, maintaining his old ailing parents and possibly servicing a loan, the Court directed him to pay Rs. 12,000/- per month on or before the 7th day of every calendar month, with arrears to be cleared within two months.

    Accordingly, the appeal was partly allowed.

    Case Title :  Vipin Kumar Nagar v. Smt. Rakhi TaungarCase Number :  FIRST APPEAL No. - 998 of 2023
    Next Story